Are possible gains endless?

In another thread I drew a parallel between PE and running: to get 4,5” in 19 months would be equal to run 100 meters in 3 seconds.

The only thing I can imagine regarding spectacular results that someone can have a very severe case of enormous inner penis, apply a lot of efforts and get 2,5”-3” in 2 years. That’s theoretically possible.

I’m in the same boat as you are. I’ve gained roughly a 1,8” EL after 2 years and 4 months of a very consistent, length-focused PE, sometimes being on (or even beyond) the edge of over-training. That’s quite a good result. And if someone states that he’s able to grow at a rate 3-4 times higher than mine over a long period of time, I’m not gonna believe his empty words, especially given that he has a commercial project in PE.

Agreed with both of you. Just taking a ruler and seeing how long 1”, 2”, 3”, 4” and 5” is should be enough to see it’s impossible to gain 4.5” in ~1.5 years.

Jon PoP a member at PeGYM.com gained 3.75” in lenght and more than 1” in girth

His gains didn’t come in a year or 2 but it took him 9 years and he was dedicated like no other.

Dustpan a former member gained 2.3” in girth in 5+years.

I think these guys are the biggest gainers in PE and I believe them.

ON the other hand I don’t believe DLD and hihgly doubtfull abut bib!!

But let’s say that BIB’s gains are true.I am pretty sure 99.5% PE’rs couln’t hang for that long.

Let me tell you a little secret about some of these guys. If you notice when they talk about their gains, they have all been 100% forthcoming with the fact that they had severe or relatively severe ED which prompted them to start PE. Now, I don’t know about you, but I don’t think it’s viable at all to measure your starting size when you are nearly incapable of getting a 100% erection.

I like to measure my post-jelq plump a lot and I think we can somewhat accurately compare it to a semi-erection. The difference between my plump and my full-blown erection is somewhere around 0.75” to 1.25” in length, depending on how plump I am. So, if that’s the maximum size that I’m able to achieve, is it really plausible for me to say I gained an inch simply by having the ability to obtain a full erection?

So, you have to be careful when you use examples of guys like you did. I’m not doubting that they gained, but I think it’s more than reasonable to cut their stated gains in half because AT LEAST half of it is just being able to get a full erection.

The biggest long-term gainers that I have come across (and find to be believable) are EquineRooster and braindrain. Search their progress logs.

Well sad. ED is not to be overlooked.

Kingpole gained 2.85” in lenght but he suffered from ED and he contributed an inch to that.

Another guy that gained 3.15” in 1 year suffered from severe ED so I am not sure how much of a lenth did he gain.Prolly around 2” withou ED.

JP is not a young guy.he started PE when he was in his late 50’s so some of his gains could also be contributed to ED.

Dustpan unfortunately also suffered from ED but still that’s a sick girth gain.

It is possible for gains to be “endless” and for there to be an absolute upper limit of gains at the same time.

Lets say a guy works very hard and gains an inch in length his first year. The second year, he works just as hard, or even harder, and gains another .5” in length. The third year, he works harder still and gets another .25” in length.

And so it goes, with the guy working ever harder to gain half as much as he did the preceding year indefinitely.

His gains are “endless” but he will never achieve a 2” length gain no matter how long he lives.

I suspect this might be how it works for most guys. There may be some maximum potential gain (different for different guys) that can be approached asymptotically but never quite achieved.

Exactly, there are a number of factors you will find with most big gainers and ED at the start is one of them. They measure their semi erect and when people later read their gains they assume they are looking at erect to erect gains, which they are not. Braindrain is one of the few big gainers I find credible due to his photos and log, but his starting age doesn’t put his gains outside of thew realm of late stage puberty.

Perhaps, but puberty can by NO MEANS even come close to explaining the dramatic increase in his size. Braindrain gained an incredible amount of size through his consistent PE work, no doubt about it.