When was the last time a girl asked you about previous lays that had bigger tits or a nicer ass?
My wife knows for a fact I have been around but any and every time the subject comes up, I know enough to answer that she was my first.
She is fully aware of the bullshit and may even slap me upside the head for being a smartass… but guess what, later that night or the next morning I know I am getting a blowjob that makes my toes curl and my butt cheecks tighten…. if I give any other answer, that is most likely not the case.
On the bright side, you aren’t married and this is a good lesson learned, don’t make the same mistake again down the road.
You can get over this and as has been mentioned, you can work on your self confidence… but unless you have a cuck fetish, this will most likely come up again.
The unique thing about this whole situation tho, BD mentioned it, you are at an amazing size already and maybe… maybe a half inch more length and girth (which is very doable with PE) puts you in that Goldilocks size range… but at the end of the day, can Pandora’s Box be Closed?
Only you can answer that.
Good luck,