Paper: Erectile dysfunction and caverno-venous leak disease
Release: March 2018
Abstract:
Erectile dysfunction is an increasing issue, especially in young man. Whereas the current treatment strategies are mostly focused on older men, young patients are seeking more for a longer lasting or defi nitive solution, rather than a life-long medical treatment. Possibly, this is a reason why currently 70% of men with erectile dysfunction are not under treatment. This aspect becomes also a socioeconomic relevance, as this generation of patients can also be called the backbone of most societies. As a logical consequence the treatment strategies in diff erent stages of life should be reviewed. Whereas various chronic disorders have been reported to be associated with elevated rates of ED including depression, diabetes, cardiovascular and neurological diseases in older men, the young generation is more suff ering from vascular problems which aff ects the storage capacity of the penis. Th e aim of this work is to review the effi ciency of newly developed minimal invasive treatment strategies for this blood storage problem, causing erectile dysfunction which is mostly described as caverno-venous leakage. Th e systematic review of the literature reveals a signifi can’t number of recent studies dealing with new minimal invasive methods to provide a potential solution of caverno-venous leakage. Even long-term results reported demonstrate considerable improvement of erectile dysfunction caused by this condition. Furthermore, 3D-Computed tomography cavernosography (CT-cavernosography) is a new technology, which can provide high-resolution images of venous drainage from any angle and shows to be very helpful for both the diagnosis of corporal veno-occlusive dysfunction and the anatomical study of the human penile venous system. Th e application of this technology may also lead to better strategies in venous leak treatment. In summary, over 30 published studies could be found in the literature with constantly good results after caverno-venous leak treatment. Altogether, 13 comparable studies including 538 patients could be found, in which a mean short-term success rate of almost 80% and a mean long term success rate of 74% was achieved. None of the studies described major complications. These encouraging results should lead to reconsider or current strategy in treatment of erectile dysfunction in young men.
Interesting quotes:
— Interestingly, venous leak disease as cause for erectile dysfunction is, in no case, only a condition found in human. Several reports demonstrate an erectile dysfunction due to corporo-venous insuffi ciency in various animal species, including bulls and boars [7-10].
It can be found that clinically bulls can also be unable to achieve erection when stimulated with an electroejaculator and in natural breeding trials. Vascular shunts can be located as cause of erectile dysfunction by serial contrast radiography of the corpus cavernosum penis. If surgical correction of the shunts is attempted by wedge resection of the tunica albuginea, this surgical correction is successful in 50% of the treated animals and the bulls can be returned to service [10].
— Simple isolated ligation of the deep dorsal vein in humans for the permanent cure of erectile dysfunction due to venous leak is up to now not recommended, due to some reported low long-term success rates [3, 11, 12].
— In this context, a compilation of outcome data of simple ligation techniques published until 2005 was discussed [14]. In the here revised literature a wide variety of success rates was found. For the authors, no single operative technique seemed to be superior to others, and a steep decline of success has to be noted with length of follow-up in single ligation procedures. But, the authors stated, that young patients with site-specific congenital, posttraumatic or post-infl ammatory leaks may be considered for vein ligation with informed consent. The choice of operation offered should be decided on available wisdom and infrastructure, the experience and preference of the operating surgeon, and the basis of the site, nature, and size of the leak [14].In contrast to these ancient findings, various modified and improved technologies with much better short- and long-term outcome have been recently described.
— Due to the fact that more recent literature dealing with new concepts of minimal invasive technologies and modern diagnostic tools our aim was to present an overview over the results from this more recent studies. A structured review of English-language articles on PubMed published till 2017 coupled with examination of tables of contents of high-impact journals to identify articles related to venous leak treatment was performed. These articles were appraised for their importance to medicine.
— Current publications explored, that 3D-CT cavernosography can provide high-resolution images of venous drainage from any angle. Th erefore, the authors conclude that the images obtained by 3D-CT cavernosography are very helpful for both the diagnosis of corporal veno-occlusive dysfunction and the anatomical study of the human penile venous system and may lead to better strategies in venous leak treatment [17–21].
— Interrestingly, penile venous surgery with ligation of the crura for venous leakage has revealed good long term results and high patient satisfaction. Th e unanimously stated conclusion from these studies is, that this technique should be off ered in young men with primary cavernosal erectile dysfunction. Young patients with normal penile arterial system and no risk factors such as diabetes had the best chance to improve erection and have a good postoperative success [22–27].
— Another reasons responsible for the good long-term outcome of the procedure might be the application of a Computed tomography cavernosography with 3D-reconstruction. The superior visualization of the complex venous draining system in a 3D-CT cavernosography before (Figure 1) and aft er sclerotherapy (Figure 2) was fi rst described by Virag [7] and could be verified by Uhl [20] and Xu [48]. Th e picture in fi gure 1 describes the complex situation in venous leakage disease and the need for a more complex renovation of the situation. It might also explain the fact, that neither simple ligation of penile veins, nor ligation of crural veins could sustainly solve the problem of venous leak disease. Furthermore, these pictures might reveal the up to now unexplained relation between erectile dysfunction and hemorrhoids [49] and possible erectile dysfunction after hemorrhoid sclerotherapy [50], due to the fact that the related veins are connected via the deep pelvic vein system. Th ese results also demonstrate the urgent need to re-explore the veinous drainage system with new higher sophisticated techniques. Th erefore, this in many cases underlying combination of cavernosal and crural insuffi ciency should be addressed in one procedure to prevent early relapse [18]. In a very recent study of Herwig and Sansalone these aspects are respected in a newly described technique, which reaches the deep dorsal vein system, as well as the crural venous system [17, 46, 47].
— When preparing the deep dorsal vein at the proximal penis shaft , the ligation of the vein distally closes the primary leak from the deep dorsal vein. In addition, the afore localized major leakage point revealed by 3D-CT cavernosography can be closed by several distal and proximal ligations. Afterwards, a 5F-Angiokatheter is placed in the proximal part of the vein. Under Valsalva-Maneuver, which has to be performed by the patients, the blood flow is reduced in the lower pelvis equal to the compression described in general surgery guidelines. When injecting polidocanol as a sclerosing agent during this time, the agent can stay longer at the venous wall and the effect of the sclerosing therapy is maximized. No residual crural or deep dorsal vein leakage could be detected after integrate combined ligation of the deep dorsal vein and antergrade sclerotherapy procedure (Figure 2). Therefore, this method is providing a therapy for deep dorsal vein and crural venous leakage in a minimal invasive setting at the same time [17, 46, 47]. With this newly described technique, at 3 month follow-up 77 out of 96 patients (80.21%) reported to have erections sufficient for vaginal insertion without the use of any drug or additional device Four (4.17%) patients did not report any improvement. Follow up with color Doppler ultrasound and CT Cavernosography revealed a new or persistent venous leakage in 8 (8.33%) of the patients. After a follow up of 12 months (n = 22) 16 (72.73%) patients still reported to have a strong enough erection for sexual intercourse. Four (18.18%) patients used PDE5 inhibitors and 2 (9.09%) patients did not report any change to their preoperative state. As before, the authors denied serious complications. These new and encouraging results in almost 540 patients show a short-term success rate of about 80% and long-term success in 73,7%. Depending on the method applied there is a slight advantage towards a combination of ligation and antegrade sclerotherapy with 80% short- term and 81,66% long-term success rate in 267 patients.
— These recent good results with this technique lead Rebonato et al. [51-53] to the statement, that even so, embolization techniques should be considered in all the cases of confirmed ED due to VOD especially in young patients. Although the technique is not always successful restoring completely the erectile function, in most cases, the patients have a satisfactory erectile function just resorting to oral pharmacotherapy (PDE5 inhibitors), delaying the time to penile prosthesis. Although further exploration in randomized controlled studies is needed, these results should lead to re-consider venous leakage treatment with these minimal invasive methods in therapy of erectile dysfunction. The described methods are minimally invasive, are carried out in local anesthesia and do not contain major risks or complications.