Originally Posted by tntjockey
Most of the guys that think it is are no where being near that size. Ask the 8x6er’s about blow jobs. I bet they feel teeth. Ask if they get a lot of anal. Hell no. So how ideal is 8x6? They may have great vaginal sex, but ideal to me is to the sex best sex in all the orifices.
Yup, I’ve had 6” girth since being sexually active, and blowjobs have generally been pathetic, and anal is typically out of the question (though some hardcore anal addicts, such as AndroNYC, claim that any woman can be coaxed into it with sufficient effort ;) ). But in my experience, the problems you’ve encountered with vaginal sex with your wife are unusual — she must have a particularly small vagina — although even with a more typically sized woman, a large girth often means that extensive foreplay is needed every time you have sex (no quickies), extra lube may be needed, and a long “recovery” period between sex sessions may be necessary. So I really don’t think that aiming for over 6” girth makes much sense, unless you’ve settled down with a woman who you know will love it (and you don’t mind the potential downsides yourself). Some PEers get carried away in their goals.
On the length side, for some reason I’ve never had a problem with 8” NBP, but many guys do report not being able to go in all the way with such length. I think this has to do with variations in penis shape or something.