Thunder's Place

The big penis and mens' sexual health source, increasing penis size around the world.

Can flaccid be longer than erect?

Theoretically, volume wise and when you think of the external surface area for a cylinder, it is possible. A long penis with a small base could have a smaller volume than a shorter penis whose base expanded (due to the engorgement during erection). I hope that your flaccid will get some internal tissues to support it’s expansion when you get erect so your penis won’t get shorter.

Originally Posted by SeekingPlatinum
I think it’s possible for flaccid size to exceed erect for one reason : if it’s long and thin when flaccid, it’ll be less long when erect. As it expands from engorgement, it’s going to increase more in width than length. I’m pretty sure there are “showers” out there who actually lose some length when they get hard for this reason.

Yup, sadly mine can be 14cm in length flaccid, but only 10.2cm girth… looks thin. I will work on it after length training, if im sucessful in adding length, that is. Your comment is spot on, i think.

Originally Posted by SeekingPlatinum
It doesn’t mean it can’t either. I’ve noticed my length is a little shorter when I’m rock hard, due to increased girth. When you stretch your penis, it gets thinner and longer. If you stretch it then get hard, you’ll notice a pulling sensation, like your penis is trying to retract even though you’re getting an erection. If you clamp your erection, as it thickens, you lose length. It’s just how it works. You can’t tell me no showers out there lose even a millimeter of length when they get hard.

Same, i lost maybe 2mm when going from EQ 9.6 - 10. Do you think this is perhaps due to a curvature you may have? For me, this is the case because of my upward curvature. Straightening it out carefully for the measurement would make it the same length as it would be at 9.6 EQ

Ah, great point about clamping an erection! I didnt even think this way.


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by keybord
I can’t say for sure no showers loose length but I have never heard of one and I’ve been on thunders several years, so I doubt it.

I appreciate your answer, I too was unable to find any threads relating to this topic.


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by KosmicKastaway
Theoretically, volume wise and when you think of the external surface area for a cylinder, it is possible. A long penis with a small base could have a smaller volume than a shorter penis whose base expanded (due to the engorgement during erection). I hope that your flaccid will get some internal tissues to support it’s expansion when you get erect so your penis won’t get shorter.

Very interesting answer. My basal girth is smaller than my midshaft, but just barely. We are talking literally 1.5mm here.
Thanks but its not actually getting shorter, its the same length! I was curious as if i continue only to have flaccid gains, if i will end up with it getting shorter! Haha sounds bizarre but i think there may be some potential in this, which of course I dont want. I want NBEL! Just curious about it all


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by LightningZee

Very interesting answer. My basal girth is smaller than my midshaft, but just barely. We are talking literally 1.5mm here.

Thanks but its not actually getting shorter, its the same length! I was curious as if i continue only to have flaccid gains, if i will end up with it getting shorter! Haha sounds bizarre but i think there may be some potential in this, which of course I dont want. I want NBEL! Just curious about it all

I don’t think you’ll have to worry about getting shorter erect. Maybe if you were clamping it could happen, but not from stretching. But I’m no expert.


Starting BPEL: 8". Starting girth: 6.5"

Goal BPEL: 9.5". Goal girth: 7.5"

Started Allknight.com's Samurai 9/2020

Okay, its been established. I’ve been out of my PF for 2 hours now and im still sporting a 14cm flaccid - 15cm when i do a simple gentle pull for literally a second. This is longer than my NBPEL as i have also just measured. Its probably not permanent, i mean heck, 2 hours. But still, just letting people here know it IS possible. And no, i’m not screwing around here. I dont do that shit.


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by LightningZee
Okay, its been established. I’ve been out of my PF for 2 hours now and I’m still sporting a 14cm flaccid - 15cm when I do a simple gentle pull for literally a second. This is longer than my NBPEL as I have also just measured. Its probably not permanent, I mean heck, 2 hours. But still, just letting people here know it IS possible. And no, I’m not screwing around here. I don’t do that shit.

You had a curve? Do you measure along the curve or bend it straight?

Originally Posted by LightningZee
Okay, its been established. I’ve been out of my PF for 2 hours now and I’m still sporting a 14cm flaccid - 15cm when I do a simple gentle pull for literally a second. This is longer than my NBPEL as I have also just measured. Its probably not permanent, I mean heck, 2 hours. But still, just letting people here know it IS possible. And no, I’m not screwing around here. I don’t do that shit.

So you have temporary flaccid gains? So the question is if it’s possible to have a bigger flaccid with temporary gains then erect? Then the answer is: yes of course it is.

Originally Posted by keybord
You had a curve? Do you measure along the curve or bend it straight?

Yes, an upward one, i estimate maybe 30 degress. When using a tape measure, i go along the curve. When using a ruler, i’ll straighten it out.


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by keybord
So you have temporary flaccid gains? So the question is if it’s possible to have a bigger flaccid with temporary gains then erect? Then the answer is: yes of course it is.

That seems to be the case right now. But still, it doesnt take away from the fact that a flaccid can be longer than erect.
To me, at first, this seemed a bizarre and almost silly topic but it got more and more real.


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by LightningZee
I havent heard of it either, flaccid being longer than erect i mean. I used to be a mostly a grower, but now seem to be a shower. Still cant shake the ”small” feeling though…
Regardless, my flaccid seems longer but erect is the same as always. At this rate, flaccid will overtake! Haha, maybe not, who knows. I’m just curious about this whole situation.

This is actually my thoughts on the concept, however as of yet there seems little information available. Perhaps the reason for this is that it is rare, or it simply doesnt happen. Thats the point of this thread though ^^

I like the sound of that. I wouldnt say “it sounds backwards” at all though, it has been said many times that flaccid gains proceed erect gains. This is my situation as of now; my general hang is 1cm shorter than erect NBPEL and when given a little shake it extends to the length of my NBPEL. Is this really so uncommon?

Yes it can because mine is (lengthwise, as per this discussion) when I come out of the PF and also for a while after (given just a gentle tug), and im well aware how to measure, thanks.

The question continues!

Ok then why you asking this question if you already have the answer? Your true flaccid length isn’t taken straight after a stretch or any routine….again measure correctly. Thanks

Originally Posted by TheTerrible

Ok then why you asking this question if you already have the answer? Your true flaccid length isn’t taken straight after a stretch or any routine….again measure correctly. Thanks

He said it was two hours later. Again, do your research before getting on your soapbox.


Starting BPEL: 8". Starting girth: 6.5"

Goal BPEL: 9.5". Goal girth: 7.5"

Started Allknight.com's Samurai 9/2020

Originally Posted by TheTerrible
Ok then why you asking this question if you already have the answer? Your true flaccid length isn’t taken straight after a stretch or any routine….again measure correctly. Thanks

I asked the question and then some cool people chimed in with useful information, then i kept people up with my situation. Also, i would think its pretty obvious that a true flaccid length wouldnt be possible to take immediately after using the PF. I’m pretty sure that i brushed on this point, not sure what confused you but i’ll try to be more clear in my future posts.

To clarify for you, flaccid is generally 1cm less in than BPEL. Giving it a small tug for a second instantly raises it for around 15 seconds to that of my BPEL, which slowly returns to its previous size of 1cm less than BPEL.
After using the PF for the days routine, It is normally the length of BPEL and then with that little tug, goes to +1 cm of my bpel. This shrinks down to my BPEL after some seconds. However, BPEL remains unchanged throughout. I said this effect lasted for 2 hours, up until i went to bed. I thought this might be of interest to others, especially PF users.

My measurements are accurate, if you are having trouble comprehending, instead of coming across a bit foolish, ask for clarification. Your tone was not appreciated.

Originally Posted by SeekingPlatinum
He said it was two hours later. Again, do your research before getting on your soapbox.

Thanks, it’s good to see somebody can conprehend my posts!


LightningZee; following Thunder's religiously for the next year!

Originally Posted by LightningZee

Thanks, it’s good to see somebody can conprehend my posts!

It was very clear to me. I can read plain English :)


Starting BPEL: 8". Starting girth: 6.5"

Goal BPEL: 9.5". Goal girth: 7.5"

Started Allknight.com's Samurai 9/2020

Originally Posted by SeekingPlatinum
He said it was two hours later. Again, do your research before getting on your soapbox.

Again what’s 2 hours got to do with true flaccid state??

Top

All times are GMT. The time now is 04:04 PM.