> More clearly: If you do your girth workouts as I described, you should make much better gains than if you quit before you feel any soreness or fatigue (in other words low intensity).
Depends. How about:
If you’ve been stalled in girth gains for several months and have never tried moderate to moderately-high intensity girth exercises before, you may experience a gain soon after easing into such a routine. Don’t expect the rate of gain to continue, and don’t conclude from the initial results that increasing the intensity even more will provide continued progress.
Doing too much too soon may toughen your tissues instead of allowing them to expand, not to mention the increased risk of injury. If you are a newbie (say 0-3 months), don’t deliberately PE to the point your shaft feels sore. Soreness is not indicative of progress.
>High intensity didn’t work for you?
In general, no. The first time I did a dedicated squeezing routine (which was intense for me at the time) I picked up a little girth in the first few weeks. I didn’t gain anything more using the same routine for several more months, though it was the start of my bad discoloration.
>Maybe it did but the gains didn’t register on the tape until later for some reason (short term shrinkage).
I once picked up a little girth after switching from an intense “girth routine” to mostly hanging with only a little girth work done on the side. It’s possible the earlier higher intensity girth work played a role. I haven’t been able to repeat those results.
>Maybe if you continued that work you would have seen even better gains than if you switched to low intensity.
During the most intense girth routine I’ve ever done (as a final test to see if high intensity would work) my circ scar began shedding small clots of blood after about 6 weeks (? on the time - I’d have to check my notes). I couldn’t continue. Discoloration was horrible. And yes, my shaft was extremely sore. My dick was sore, ugly and discolored. No permanent gain from that.
Also, I didn’t gain any length from a good hanging routine (I should have based on past experience) done several months after that super intense girth routine, which further confirmed my suspicion that highly intense work causes a great deal of toughening.
>Maybe your measuring changed.
Same tape and ruler since the beginning. I’ve always been good about measuring consistently.
>Maybe I’m full of shit lol.
No. I agree with you, mostly, if the advice is put in context. I just don’t want newbies rushing to make their shafts sore thinking soreness is the key to progress. It isn’t. They should stick with the basic lower intensity techniques and get the most progress possible out of them before moving on.
However, after gains have thoroughly played out from the milder stuff, it’s time to increase intensity. This often results in a gain. From reports here, and my own experience, it seems to be mostly a one time thing. Pick up 1/16”, 1/8”, 1/4” or whatever, then that’s it. There are a few exceptions, but in general this seems to be the case. Maybe I’m wrong.
Not long after the Horse440’s were introduced several guys made some decent initial gains, then couldn’t get any more. They had probably never done such intense girth work. They eeked out some expansion their tunicas had previously been reluctant to offer. So, I think bumping up the intensity is good in some cases, mostly as a last hurrah.
There will always be exceptions. Guys who gain girth relatively easily (who usually aren’t the same ones wanting more girth) may respond differently from girth “hardgainers.”