I think we are trying to be logical and reasonable like men tend to do but it isn’t that simple. For example:
You have 4 guys each with identical size penis’ (All 7*5.75 for example) One guy is white of average height, another guy is a short Asian, another is a giant, a 7ft man with wide shoulders and another is a very well built tall black guy - Do we think each of the guys would get the same response to their dicks?
Do we think women would be raving about their well hung 7ft tall basketball player partner with his 7 inch dick? I don’t think so, I would personally feel slightly sorry for that guy as I imagine he will have encountered a lot of disappointed faces as the expectation would have been so high. However I imagine the short Asian or the average white guy would be enthusiastically received. Likewise would the large black guy be considered large or borderline acceptable? My personal opinion is that women don’t have a clue about size - they just want something to look large and unexpected. My point is that there is an pre-conceived expectation in women’s minds and if a man can fulfill that and also have a large looking dick.. He is hung (in their subjective opinion)
If subjectivity is not accepted and the quest here is for what is definitively classed as well hung - then I think we have to start looking in the 8*6 range where the size is statistically rare. E.g if this was a basketball players forum and this same thread arose, do you not think the figures would be slightly larger than here where I imagine there is a more diverse cross section of males?