C Guy,
I saw your post and it interested me for the reasons you mentioned at the start. I too have had my pains with trying to get things right with the hanger and wanted to offer some ideas of what has helped me. I see you have tried just about everything and so have I. Bib suggested trying all kinds of different adjustments, wrapping etc and I certainly have.
I guess I’m kinda like a pitbull when it comes to things like this cause I usually don’t let up until I figure it out. Anyway, it looks like we are about the same flaccid girth, I’m 4.5” as well, using tee-shirt as the first layer and coach brand sports wrap as second layer (self sticking kind).
Here’s the thing. I’ve been playing with all kinds of adjustments, front to back, up and down, you name it.. and come up with what I think is the absolute best for my current situation. Maybe you can give it a go and see if it helps as well. What I did is:
Adjusted hanger (bottom hex-nuts) to these settings for a fairly radical “Toe-In” adjustment. Here’s the measurements I got on mine (Bib starter).
Front hex-nut distance is: 5/8”
Rear Hex-net distance is: 13/16”
Next, wrap rather loosely with both wraps mid-shaft or just behind the cir- scar. Then, pulling by the head w/ left hand, pull the wrapping down toward the base some. Attach the hanger and tighten slightly- pulling/ squeezing the blood from the head (all your basic stuff there).
Now tighten the hanger very (or close to) tight. The teeth on mine mesh pretty much all the way together. This is a pretty tight fit! You probably already know this but there will more skin in front of the hanger but I figure it will stretch with time anyway.
Now, the hanger will move forward some (actually feel it in the shaft) but the good news is it will ” lock-up” back behind the head. In this configuration, I’ve found it to stay well back from the head as it’s actually pushing internal structure ahead of it.
Hanging this way I now have absolutely 0 slippage! Granted the head does get a little purple-ish and cool but Im learning to deal with that (since my head hasn’t fell off yet) hehe. I had a bad slippage problem as well and this has really solved that for me. Give it a shot, can’t hurt…right?
in9