Bathmate Different Than Air Pump With Water?

Hi, I have been pumping on and off for years. Frequently enough that I should have seen some gains by now, yet have seen very minimal gains. Immediately after a pump feels great but the next day the increased engorgement and edema have gone away an no permanent gains are remaining. This has led me to get very discouraged with pumping and begin hanging. However, I want girth increase and I see great reviews (skeptical if they are all real) on the bathmate. So my question is this:

- have you had success with permanent girth gains by using primarily a bath mate consistently?

- Does a bath mate function any differently than an air pump with water in the cylinder? Say a leluv 9” cylinder. Curious because I already have some of those I could try rather than spending $100 on a bath mate.

Thanks in advance!!

The biggest difference is having a gauge so you can get repeatable results.

So you’re saying using an air pump with a gauge but filling the cylinder with water would work better than a bath mate?

The conventional cylinder with a pump with a gauge should produce the best results. I have not used a Bathmate myself, but from what I have read on this and other sites, there is no advantage to a Bathmate, the consensus seems to be that the right sized conventional cylinder, used wet or dry with a gauge is the best way to pump. Are you looking for length, girth, or both? What size do you have now? How on and off have you been in your routine?

Thanks Viking guy,

I would like both length and girth, but girth is really my top priority. I’m currently just shy of 8” and about 5.5 MEG. When I say I’m on and off, I mean I have been pumping for about 5 or 6 years. Some moths I will be consistent with doing it 4 days a week. Some times I get discouraged or am traveling and go a few weeks without doing it at all and just do a little jelking.

I know some people with say consistency is key, but after having thousands of pump sessions under my belt in the last several years I would think I should have cemented some gains.

Yes!

Thank you, sir! Always appreciate the info and quick responses!