Did I choose the right size?

I just ordered a velseal 1.75” tube and am thinking it might be too big.

I’m 4.75 midshaft, 5.625 at the base and felt that a 1.5” would not give me a great seal at the base.

I’m going for girth only, not too concerned with length at the moment. Should I have gone with a 1.5”?

1.75*3.14= 5.495

Should work.

Ed

That should fit well for you. Do a little shaving around the base of your shaft. Use vaseline or a good, thick gel lube on the base of the tube to augment the seal.