Tube circumference for girth

I know one is supposed to pick a tube with a circumference that is v. close to their erect circumference. I want to work only/mainly on GIRTH with the pumping, so is it better for me to get a tube much wider than my erect girth? I am not too concerned with length gains at the moment.

v. close ??

If you know the tube diameter with a circumference that equals your erect circumference, pick a tube .25 inch larger in diameter and go with that. So if a 1.75 inch diameter tube matches your circumference, buy a 2.0 inch tube.

gprent- not trying to pick a fight as I agree with your post. (but). :-) I’ve noticed with myself that although my EG is 5.75 I’m more comfortable in a 2.25” tube instead of the 2.0 because I’m right at 2” wide and find that milking the tube can produce a donut from all the friction, even with lube, so I wonder if width should be considered as well as overall girth.

Note also that my base girth is just over 6 and after a few minutes I do pack up the bottom couple of inches of the 2.25 tube.

MrP-P makes a good point. Shape of the cock counts, too. We’re not all round. If you are sort of flattened (ovoid) dorsally or even ventrally, a slightly larger tube might do better to avoid brush-burn.

hey guys,
I too am wondering about this whole tube size question. I am wider than deeper , with a bit over 5.2 ~ starting girth I am over 1 3/4 wide from base up past mid-shaft, but top to bottom I’m more like an inch and a half. I put this question out before and I think avocet replied back that the 2” tube i went with was probably my best bet,but I wonder if I should invest in a 1 3/4 tube also. would less space around the base give any better results. I have been pumping sporadically for about one month, only on any sort of routine for the last couple of weeks, and what I am seeing is this.
- the first quarter inch of shaft is packing complete , just a couple inches
- side to side the upper side is packing again about halfway up the shaft from base
- base to mid-shaft is already over 1/4 inch thicker ( only pumping 1 month and I sit here 48 hrs since last session with a 1/4 thicker dick I’m hoping that’s a good sign its permanent)

but, I have this huge 1/2 gap from top to bottom about 3/4 to 2/3 way up the shaft……….does the gap effect anything,would i be better off with the 1 3/4 where i would likely pack it all the way up the tube?if I stick with the 2” will I likely eventually pack it all the way up?I mean don’t get me wrong.I’m ecstatic with the gains so fast, I was blown away when I measured just for kicks and had results so fast,but if the smaller tube would facilitate progress then it would be $100 well spent in my opinion.

so what do you guys thing….smaller snug fit that I can fill out completely top to bottom….or leave a little room to grow in the 2” and maybe/probably/possibly pack it out top to bottom over time?????/

so nobody has any experience/opinion on whether a smaller tube with some but not much room to expand or a larger tube is better for girth gains??????