Flaccid to Erect to Permanent?

I would like to ask anyone who happens across this thread and has been PEing for 3 months or more to weigh in on their experiences with how penile development occurs. I think it would be a prime example of a subject for data collecting that could benefit the community, especially newcomers to PE and for anyone who is interested in this interesting field.

So the questions are as follows:

1: Did you see flaccid improvement or erect improvement first?

2: How long did it take for one to become the other?

3: How long would you say it took for these to become permanent gains (or at least some improvement even after having a week or more off)?

P.S. Note that I use the term “improvement” over commonly said “gains” here. This is because I believe “gains” should only be used as a term to denote solidified enhancement.

I appreciate your time!

1. Depends on what I do
If I do stretching type of Pe, I get flaccid first.
If I do jelqing I get erect gains first

2. It takes about a month or two too see those gains translate to each other.

3. I think a year, I don’t know if my gains are fully permanent and I don’t want to take a chance and find out.

Thanks, very interested in your thoughts on how the stretching causes flaccid gains first and jelqing causes erect gains! I hadn’t thought of this myself, but after stretching this past week (and not doing so for the month before) I would have to agree with you.

Haha fair enough on that last point, my thoughts exactly! This is best answered by those who have done so already.

Anybody else care to “weigh” in? This data collection will be for the benefit of the community :)

I don’t trust ordinary flaccid measurements - they vary too much. Bone-pressed, flaccid-stretched length (BPFSL) is reasonably consistent, though. By “flaccid” did you mean BPFSL?

Question 3: How long would you say it took for these to become permanent gains….?
Personally, I don’t think that we can keep “permanent gains”,for me it’s like a “work out at the gym”.
If you stop, you will probably lose % of your gain.
DJ8

After 5 years of PE, when it’s hanging heavy, my flaccid is now bigger than my old erect size. When it’s turtling, there is only a slight size difference.

When I started out, I had gains in both within weeks.

I can appreciate that and I totally agree. I’ve found my flaccid regularly fluctuates between 10.5cm and 12cm, even within a minute of measuring. As such, BPFSL is a more consistent way of measuring, I should have stated as such. Thanks for the enlightenment!