There are some fundamental flaws here…
First, I cannot see how a psych can authorize something on the level of Paxil for a condition that exists for a few days out of the month (if I understand the situation correctly). You do not take a daily heavy-duty psych drug daily for such a problem.
The issue, if it’s PMS related, is one of hormones and not a psychiatric condition. Therefore, you look at this from a situation of what is going on with the hormones and how can she take something (during that time period) that will benevolently readjust the hormones or ease the issue. Look at herbal remedies first. Always go there before you pull the trigger on heavy meds. This isn’t to say that in some cases heavy duties aren’t necessary but this clearly doesn’t appear to be it.
As a society we’ve lost sight of why such heavy duty psych drugs were first developed years ago. Nowadays, they are clearly being misused for a number of reasons. You can blame both the medical field for that and the non-medical society as well. They are both guilty.
The fact is that I’ve watched several people absolutely CHANGE their personality under the influence of these drugs. In particular a woman that I attended high school with and am still close with 20+ years later. She always had terrible PMS and was ultra-moody. Undoubtedly hormonal in her case. She has since gone to some herbal thing (after a vicious fight to get off the meds) that boosts her seratonin levels, which were almost non-existant. She’s a great friend and I felt like I had lost her during all that time. One cannot make medical decisions for another, as we all know.
Look, I think there are situations where herbal is right and ones where meds are right. The diff is that herbals don’t do heavy personality changes that can’t be easily reversed or muted (simply by discontinuation). I just don’t like how this psych has handled this at all.
Also, 1quest, you mentioned that she had some anxiety about it. Then shes says it’s not an issue. Well, which is it? Personally, if her personality is changing then I would be concerned. And contradictory expressions are a sign of that (to me). Maybe she’s not crying and all that right now, but has it taken other things out of her personality?? That is bad shit, man. Bad. That is what heavy stuff can do to a person - really alter signifigant parts of their personality. Mute them, so to speak, in many ways. And it usually takes a few years of such miserableness to understand what the meds have in fact done to the person (and the marriage, by consequence).
I take St. John’s twice a day. It does wonders for me and it’s fine. But if it didn’t then I’d rather live with the unmedicated me than what happens so often when people become medicated. At least I know that person and can deal and be in control. I personally have seen some people literally brain-scorched by irresponsible psychs. They will never be the same.
I say, address the problem (hormones) by doing a lot of research and try various things. Don’t give your wife and your relationship into the hands of a psych who doesn’t have to endure the ramifications of their prescriptions. I just think they go nuclear too quickly instead of working up the scale with stuff.
Well, I tried to make that as neutral as I could, but I am just sooo pissed off when I think of all my friend’s marriages that have been (almost to a man and woman) detrimentally affected by careless prescription writers (which is what many, many psychs are).
Be careful when you mess with the brain.
-BH