Fauxreal,
I believe studies have shown that average is 5 1/2 - 6 1/2 in NBEL, and 5 in EG.
What I suggest is throwing out everything less than and including 6”. Now we are only looking at above average figures. With this data there should be a new bell curve showing what is “average” for the above average group. I couldn’t find the graph just now, but I have seen it in the past and I believe it correlates well with JC’s poll. That is 7” NBEL, 5.5”EG.
So, I guess what I am stating is, 7 x 5.5 could be considered the threshold of “Big”. Going back to the original question: “what’s for you folks (reasonably) “big”?”, I would say if you can step over the threshold then you are reasonably big.
I agree that 8” is big, I just don’t know if I would consider it “reasonable” - as in realistically attainable.
I was dreaming when I thought it couldn't done, but now I know I have work to do.
Came with: NBPEL 5.875, EG @ Scarline 4.5 Mustered up: 7 x 5 Looking for: 9 x 6 Will settle for: 8 x 5.5