Do you think girth or length makes you look bigger?

Length definitely. Mine looks smaller than a lot of members on here and thats only due to the girth of it. It looks short and stumpy when its average and fat.

When I have some extra girth due to working out or clamping, as little as 2/5 of an inch, my penis looks IMMENSE.

I think in those cases it looks a lot bigger than some more length would make it.

Thanks SpaceDude. Still hammerin’ away for girth and staying motivated. I don’t pump often because it leaves it all puffy but the other night I did and I was close to my goal of 8.5” BPEL and 6” EG. I couldn’t believe what I was looking at. HUGE and good proportion.

Couldn’t agree more!
I’m 8” BPEL (my stats are NBP) and due to me having “only” 5” girth, my penis just does not look big :(

With a girth over average (such as yours) an 8 inch penis is definitely big.

Me too.

Mine is about 6,5 by 5,5 or so and the girth makes it look shooooort, I want more length!

I beg to differ.

I think it’s my girth that makes it look big.

I would say girth.

I allways hated my penis for being so thin. Mostly thin at the top of the glans that made it look small.

Both visually and in actual fact, girth is what makes you huge.

That is because girth affects your penis volume way more than length does. And why is that? It’s because to volume of a cylinder equals pi times the radius squared times the height. Because the radius is squared in the equation, a small increase in the radius makes a large increase in the volume. So as your girth increases, your penis volume goes way up.

Here is just one of several threads on the subject: Measuring the whole picture - Volume

Yes I agree with you girth makes me feel better. I’m 5.5” in diameter. My wife loves it.

I’m going with girth as well.

If I had a choice between an 8”x5” or 7”x6” size, no doubt I’m going with 7”x6”.

You’re not 5.5 in diameter. That would be the most absurd cock in the history of mankind.

You’re 5.5 in circumference.

It’s a hard call. :) I’d do alot for more girth but once you get past a certain length I don’t think I’d trade it for anything. At where I’m at I wouldn’t trade more girth for less length, it’s a proportion thing for me.