Pump vs Extender?

Even if you enter the cylinder erect when you come out you won’t be erect. You will be thicker and longer but you won’t be erect

So is it recommended to enter the cylinder erect? I read the pumping 101 manual and it didnt clearly state that.. My penomet says to put my flaccid penis in it and pump.

I have experimented with both methods, even using flaccid pumping for many months with no real success. I have recently started pumping erect and it is by far better in my opinion. It feels like my unit is already at al almost full expanded state when entering the cylinder and the pump pushes it that little further beyond. When I flaccid pump it takes so long to even close to that fully engorged state and even then it doesn’t “feel” the same - it feels like I am just getting my penis to that fully expanded state, rather than pushing it past it (with erect pumping).

Would pumping after a routine be better for gains then edging?

My best and quickest gains came from pumping erect. I found it also minimizes fluid build up.

I started out vacuum pumping, then bought a bathmate, so for a year and a half I pumped and jelqed only made 1 inch length and 3/4 inch girth. I was in a regular condom before I started ended up in an magnum xl, took off three months and was still in the xl when I came back. My gains have been mostly permanent. Although lately I have been tossing around the thought of a size genetics as my girth is slowly catching my length. I had also been clamping recently too. If I could only get one, for me it would be the pump, if I could go back it would be a penomet as I bought an x40 after I out grew my her hercules. Nothing but problems with my x40, not very happy with it. Loved the hercules pump though, no muss no fuss.

Lugnutz, how often were you pumping with the Hercules?

I was pumping 5 on 2 off, I took saturday and sunday off. I was doing the warm up in the shower and 15 mins with the bathmate 5 min jelq after then 15 min vacuum pumping then about 15 mins jelq. Now I do a modified 4 on 3 off and some sometimes pump on the odd 5th day, I just listen to my body. I also do natural supplement, this may be the wrong place to post but if someone could direct me right right place I’ll gladly post. I’m going to post some before and after too

+10 to this

So, 5 days of 1/2 hr pump time. Very good. You can set up a progress thread in the members section.

Not sure if I had enough posts yet, but working on it lol. Just trying to find my early before pics. Thanks Ecto

I am incorporating both devices (KR extender and a pumptoys cylinder) after about 4 months of the newbie routine. Looking to build a regimin around those two tools as well keep on doing jelqs and kegels. Only been at the extender for about 3 weeks and just got started pumping, early feelings is that the synergy of the two should be a good combination for growth. Any others doing extending/pumping together?

I have been pumping for over five years and extending for four years. I have gained 1 inch in both length and girth. I attribute my girth gains to pumping and my length gains to extending.