What's the most widely successful method?

Unfortunately I didn’t take any measurements during the time I did pumping. I really did just to be thicker for a few hours to satisfy my wife better, I never believed that gains could be permanent (until I found these forums just recently). So I started pumping at about 7inHg and eventually got up to 15inHg of vacuum for periods of no more then about 20min, once a day or every other day (when ever I had sex). I believe, but have no stats to prove, that my thickness increased. Don’t know at all about length.

bump

Has anyone gotten any gains from edging? I’ve heard it works well for some people. I’m just starting to try it.

tbluraider:

No more benefit than having a rock-hard erection for thirty minutes during the night; a not at all common event.

Errata: “a not at all uncommon event”

I actually gained about 1/4” from edging.

Newbie routine is all I’ve done, but it works well and I like it. I saw an almost immediate gain of .5” in length followed by some noticeable girth gain (not yet quantified) and a little more length. I’m going to do another measurement in about a month, since I don’t like to measure too frequently.