Originally Posted by bubba77
Modesto, question for you about your “this is biology not physics” hanging comment. How can you say that with a steady increase in weight, say up to even 50 lbs, a person’s tissue would not respond by expanding to accommodate the stress? I understand that you didn’t gain anything from 5lb to 25 lbs…but I disagree that hanging is biology not physics.
I’m glad that you’re gaining, Bubba77. My statement about PE not being about physics is simply to say that the penis is not the same as a steel rod or a length of wire. It is part of a living organism. It doesn’t merely comply with forces imposed on it, but rather adapts and responds to those forces through biological processes.
Of course the body is not immune to physics—everything physical is subject the laws of physics. The problem is when people infer that because a wire does one thing when it is pulled, a penis will do the same. Not so.
The cells in the penis will respond to applied force by doing something. Sometimes, or for some guys, the tissues proliferate and the penis grows. Sometimes the tissues become inflamed and contract. I actually LOST 1/4” BPFSL when I started hanging over 15#. My body did just the opposite of what an oversimplified model of the physics would predict.
Ultimately, physics does triumph. But maybe not the way you expect. It may be possible to strap 500 pounds to your dick and truly subject it to rapid plastic deformation, just like what happens when you stretch a wire. But what will happen then. It may simply stretch 1/8” and suddenly snap clean off. It all depends on the modulus of elasticity.
At any rate, PE induced forces don’t go anywhere near the plastic limit of our tissues. If we grew from plastic deformation, growth would be instantaneous. All we’d need to do is strap on the weight, let it hang for 1 second, and then remove it to reveal our permanently elongated (and probably dead) dicks. It obviously doesn’t work this way. Something else is going on.