Can pumping replace jelqing in the newbie routine

Hi guys, my question is if moderate pumping can replace jelqing in the newbie routine. I’m asking, because I get turkey neck from jelqing.

I think pumping can make jelqing easier because it increases the blood capacity, pumping does not push the blood in and out so I’m not sure if it will be permanent in the end

Pumping will not help you grow, you are better off jelqing and if you get turkey neck’s then may don’t squeeze so hard, but pumping is not great it will look good when you take the pump off but it’s just from blood flow that will soon go away.

Edit: How long have you been on the Newbie Routine, Simon?

Are you saying that pumping is a waste of time and that you will not get any permanent gains?

It’s been my experience as well, pumping is a waste of time, yes I agree with that assessment.

2 month, but I’m only doing stretching.

Try some loose-gripped wet-jelqs Si. Jelqing is one of the foundation exercises; there are many benefits to doing at least a little jelqing. Maybe you should reconsider your decision, especially when taking into account the experiences of members who have previously pumped…

Lot of guys in the pumpers forum will strongly disagree with you.