I myself have been on the quest of determining what the "ideal size" is, but after some time you realize that there is no such thing. Most women tend to think way less about penis size than men. They simply want to have a good time.
Originally Posted by SmartCookie
So it occurred to me that it makes much more sense to ask guys who slept with a lot of women what penis size is ideal. Everybody on this forum knows their exact size and also what the reactions were during sex so please, can you help me with this question of ideal size?
That is an interesting approach. You are right that I know my exact size and I know what the reactions were, but I have never owned a substantially different penis, so I cannot compare their reactions relative to a different size. Everytime the subject was brought up with any of my long-term partners, they always refered to it as perfect or ideal. So that is your data point from my side. My length is between 7 and 7.5 inches (~18-19cm) bone pressed and 6.5 to 7 inches non-bone pressed (~16.5-17.5cm) depending on how I measure. My girth is around 5.3 (~13.5cm) mid-shaft and 5.8 (~14.75cm) at the base. This doesn’t mean that this is THE ideal size, it means that it was probably more than sufficient for the sexual partners that I encountered.
That being said, I am fairly confident that they would have reacted the same way if it was slightly smaller or bigger. Thus, it is more productive to think about "optimal range" rather than "ideal size". The reason for that is that basically you want to reach the right spots. After a certain size (somewhere around average for most women) the difference becomes how you reach these spots. Different sizes will provide different experiences, but this doesn’t mean that one is better than the other. You could practically be an ideal lover with an avarage-sized penis.
In terms of reactions during sex, they have varied with different partners and in different situations. With my length I have bottomed out most of my partners in deeper positions (e.g. legs on shoulders), but haven’t noticed any substantial problems in more shallow positions. Thus, if I had a longer penis, I would have avoided these deeper positions and this wouldn’t make me a better or a worse lover. In terms of circumference, they pretty much always make the O face upon insertion. Once they are worked up, there has never been an issue and they can easily take all of the girth. It starts to become a "problem" after longer sessions of rough sex.
In order to make a girl orgasm from penetration, I have to pick the right angle, usually applying pressure on the anterior wall of her vagina (assuming she is vaginally orgasmic). When I do that, the question of girth becomes almost irrelevant. If I aimlessly bang in and out, I would rarely make my girlfriend cum. If I packed some extra girth, it would probably happen a bit more often, but that is still irrelevant. Why? Because when I want to make her orgasm I change the angle and achieve the result in ~10 seconds. With extra girth she would get sore more quickly and probably wouldn’t be able to cum as many times. Right now I can easily make her orgasm more than 10 times within a regular 20 minutes session and this is only a matter of angle. And even with extra girth I would still be more efficient by applying pressure on the right spots.
Originally Posted by SmartCookie
How much more would you increase your size if you were in my place?
0cm.
This is assuming that I had a healthy mind and could think rationally. The reason why I am here is because I, like many others on the forum, suffer from Penile dysmorphic disorder. Add in some anxiety to the mixture and you have an insecure individual who tries to fix something that isn’t broken.
Your size is a valid answer to the question in your title. As you said, it is above average and I can assure you it is opitmal for most women. You can hit all the right spots with your member.
"Most" women is a very key word here. Just like with penises, vaginas come in different sizes. Every once in a while you could encounter a woman that craves a huge cock and that’s okay. For every such woman you would usually have a tiny petite girl that cannot handle anything above average. That being said, the vast majority of women are average and you could offer an optimal experience for them. Adding some size wouldn’t make a difference in terms of your ability to deliver pleasure.
Let me tell you what does make a HUGE difference though: erection quality. My erections are pretty much always good. But every once in a while they are outstanding and I could see the reaction in my girlfriends eyes. So my advice would be to focus on your health and improving your erections even further (research kegels).
And if you want further reassurence that you don’t need extra size, you can check what the research shows. A study from 2015 indicates that women prefer size that is above average, but not big: 16cm length and 12.2cm circumference (Women’s Preferences for Penis Size: A New Research Method Using Selection among 3D Models | PLOS ONE). You seem to already be a tiny bit above the "ideal" according to the study. And it is based on women being shown actual 3D models and not on asking questions about dimensions.