“Mightn’t this suggest to me that I should consider looking at what they’re doing differently? I know that there’s no guarantees that what they’re doing will work for me, but still…”
Which was pretty much ONE of the points *I* was coming to - if you find that YOU are spending LOT more time with little or no gains, compared to even a loose and “unscientific” standard - wouldn’t you want to know that just MAYBE you needed to do something different?
PLUS, if you are anewbie, and had hopes of significant gains in a relatively short period of time - a FALSE hope for most, and discouraging - wouldn’t you like to see at least SOME sort of outline as to what is likely to be involved - to decide if it’s even worth your getting started with?
I know *I* would prefer some form of honest estimate - up front, even a loose one - rather than a “well, everyone is different - you’ll just have to try it for a while and see what happens in your case…
As for my own progress - I haven’t practiced enough of a regular schedule to even come up with a time vs inch - been 2 years for a 1 inch length, 1+ inch girth (approx) gain and about 2 inch flaccid hang gain, currently at about 7” length x 6” mid-shaft, 6.5 towards the base - wish I had better track of time involved - sorry… Frankly, it took lots longer than *I* had expected or hoped… But that’s partly due to my admitted failure to maintain a decent daily schedule, no excuses…