How Big is "Too Big"? (post your opinion)

How big is too big?

There are plenty of threads on ideal size but just how big is “too big”?

How big is “too big”

For guys themselves, especially reading these forums, is anything too big? Probably yes, if not within proportional limits of our body types, but even then…

For men with regular partners, “too big” is whatever becomes uncomfortable for their partner.

But how many guys here meet their initial goals and then decide that isn’t enough?

I think anything above 7 inch girth and 11 inch length is just way too big to use.

At the moment an 8 x 6 is the maximum size for me. The 9 x 7 goal that some guys have is what I find to big.

For a while I thought 9 inches was too big but I read a post by a female thunders member who said her ideal length was 8” nbp, which for me translates to about 9” BPEL (my original goal was BPEL 8.5)

As for girth, for me I think 6.5” would be the upper limit.

Too big for me would be a schlong that I can not hide with a little creative effort. I know some of you think that sounds crazy, and would love a huge bulge to ruin the minds of innocent young women everywhere. I, however, see a giant phallus bugging out of my pants under inappropriate circumstances as a real social problem.

I want 8” or 8.5” in length as a final measurement. Based on my beginning stats that may take a while. I would like to stop my girth at about 6.5” (which is an even loftier goal). I think this would be the top-end of what my wife can handle.

Too big (for me) would be >10” in length or >7” in girth of Erect Phallus.

I think I’ll stop when I get to 16 inches.

I don’t think I will ever feel like mine’s too big, even after I reach my goals.

Now when I’m talking about dicks my wife has had in the past, then anything over 4”x3” is too big. I want her to think of me when it comes to the Cock of the Walk.

But, she’s been with some HUGE guys in the past. I knew one of them. The fucker could make Seattle Slew blush.

So you changed your goal to 9” BPEL based on the opinion of one female member? May be you changed it because your original goal wasn’t far off.

I based my original goals on the data at penissizedebate.com , but at the time I decided on those goals I didn’t know whether the length figures were BPEL or NBPEL, so I was kind of aiming for 8.5"BPEL for a 7.5"NBPEL…

…I’ve been wondering for a while if I should increase my goal to 9"BPEL for 8"NBPEL and, yes, that one post influenced me to increase my goal just a little.

Plus, if the penissizedebate.com figures are bogus, why not aim for 9"BPEL?

What I need to know is how big is too big?

When does a functional cock become a "non-functional" "show-cock"?

How nice to be considering this question. I spend my time thinking about how small is TOO SMALL. However, 8x6 sounds about perfect!

In that case I think that it is the girth of your cock that determines whether it is functional or not.

Geez Fantastic, do you think you could post another link to that joint? That shit costs us in the search engine wars.

Sorry Thunder I had no idea — I’m not too clued up on how these things work (thought I was just being thorough)

You can delete the post if it’s that big a deal

I think that the porno sizes get ridiculous sometimes like Mandingo. Also Lex Steele who I saw on HBO stating that he has to be careful because he was hurting girls. I think Steele is about 10” long easily and Mandingo is larger. I am rather large by the standards of “penissizedebate” noted above. I’ve never really had problems although at times I had to be careful; no “banging” so to speak, although a couple of women could take that also.

So guys women can take 9” but above that ( like 10”+) I believe you are in freak show range needing the low percentile of women who can handle or desire the big ones.