I'm about ready to give up. Extender users please comment.

Only one inch. Lol. Try .25” in a couple years. I haven’t had any luck with the extender (x4) either. 1000+ hrs. Btw I know your not totally happy wuth your size but I would be thrilled to be 7”NBP X 5.5. Thats my end goal.

I was doing great with my extender for a few months but then it broke (the strap) so am now ordering a new piece off ebay. In the mean time, my only PE (the past 10 days) has been clamping. Every other day, 4 to 5 sets of 8 minutes. Thats it (besides daily stretching that probably only accounts for about 20 minutes total time). I have some slight ED issues but do feel like the clamping has been helping my girth. My length has hit a virtual stand still (about your length and slightly less than your girth) over the last several years so am going to give the extender a good 6 to 9 months but for now, clamping seems to be helping with some nice gain otherwise (at least it feels and looks that way as have not measured yet).

Is this a joke?

I use the size genetics and the vlc tugger attachment it is the way to go if you are uncut . I love it where it 8 to 12 hours a day and I have gained a half inch in 4 months . I also bathmate for 20 min each morning so it might not be just the sizegentics but this routine is working for me. I couldn’t even where the strap or nose for longer then an hour at a time now I where it for up to 6 hours at a time no pain . Ron the maker of the vlc will build it custom size for you if you just give him your measurements. Anyways that’s the only way I’d ever where the extender and wanted to share that with everyone cause before that I almost threw out my sizegentics now I love to use it.

Bro, be happy you have gained anything. I gained a pubic hair and been at it for years on and off. How do you think I feel?

How old are you? Pumping will help that stretcher do its work. Years ago I got Monkeybar’s original stretcher. Autoextender Penis Enlargement Device Pumping a couple of times a week following just an hour with the extender has really worked. Also get some Catauba extract from Vitamin Shop and use every other day. It is supposed to promote growth. Just use an extender that does not have a rope but more of a clamp as with the bib hanger after a hot shower to loosen up the ligaments. Like many others here, I’ve been at it for a while.

To OP, I don’t know if someone else hit on this but I probably didn’t have any gains at all from extenders until I was stretching past my erect length. Before PE I was definitely a grower not shower, and I bought the X4 labs. I wasn’t able to stretch as flaccid past my erect length for probably the first 500 hours. I ended up having to drop another $150 to buy extender bars and then was finally able to have a stretch that was longer than erect (probably .25 inch longer than erect length). That’s when I finally started to see gains. Don’t give up.