Heavy weights or ADS---which is better for length

I am curious if anyone has opinions on whether hanging with significant weights (over 5 or 10 lbs) or an ADS is better for length gains. I am doing manual stretches now, for the past week, seen weird stuff happen……sometimes longer erections already, yet sometimes shorter than normal erections also (WTF!?). I am worried manual stretching wont be enough in the long run (pun intended).
I have been saving up money, and am thinking of getting one or the other (a BIB or an ADS), but need your opinions/guidance as to what you think will work better for length gains (I gain girth easily and fast with just hand jelqs).

Thanks

Just my opinion, save up your $ and get a bib. Add a belt to the there/cotton wrap you use to hang and viola! You have an ADS.

Some guys get gains from manual stretching etc. If it wasn’t for hanging my dick would still be the same size.

So a bib doubles as a ADS?
Is it cumbersome underneath jeans? I don’t want anyone to notice if I wear an ADS. But I think wearing the ADS when not hanging is the surefire way to ensure that the healing done while not hanging is done with the most benefit, obviously, so the Bib may be the right choice for me.we’ll see.