Originally Posted by gprent
Actually the best size cylinder for you is a 1.75" diameter. Here is our sizing table:Selecting Your Cylinder Size
A 2" tube would be too large and you would have trouble with your scrotum and balls being sucked into tube. A 2.5" tube would be big enough to pump your entire package, cock and balls.
Thank you I will listen to your advice and the advice of others in this thread and get the 1.75!
Originally Posted by Don Logan
This is a very good question. I thought the same thing a while back and bought an oversized cylinder. But it really doesn’t work that way. You have to precisely size the pump, per gprent’s recommendation, above.
I have a cheap pump that is something like 2.75 I think? It’s been a NIGHTMARE. Sometimes I have great pump sessions and other times after 15 mins my balls get sucked into the tube and it hurts.
Originally Posted by Didgeridoo
Are you 4.8in at the base or more? I’m 5 inches mid shaft but I can pack a 2" in tube at the base without issues.
I am 4.7 at the base and 4.8 midshaft I’m not sure if that’s normal to be thicker midshaft than the base but that is the case for me
Originally Posted by Viking Guy
I would go with a 3.5 or larger and do the whole package..
Thanks for the advice is there any benefits to doing the whole package?
Originally Posted by c3ifador
DiamondHusky, friend you think your 12,2cm girth dick will fit in a 16,05cm girth cylinder? Think twice, your girth does not fit into 2" diameter cylinder because there is your penis and there is skin, the pressure will expand both, it is obvious that the lack of meat you have will make your pubic skin being the one pushed and expanded the most, that means no dick gains, best option for you is 1.75" diameter. If you buy the 2.5" diameter cylinder, that means 20,06cm girth, you better put your whole package and yet you will gain lots of skin.
Thank you c3ifador for breaking the numbers down to me like that. You’re right. I am going to get the 1.75
Originally Posted by LittleEngine
I’ve been using a 1.75” cylinder since I began pumping seven years ago. I did have a larger cylinder as I could not go smaller with the Bathmate, as gprent pointed out, my balls would get sucked up quite often.My girth has increases from 4.50” to 5.00” and the 1.75” cylinder is still right for me. To pack a 2.00” cylinder I would have to take on more edema than I would prefer.
My recommendation is as others have stated, size for where you are now.
Thanks LittleEngine. I’m glad to hear that the consensus is for me to get the 1.75 that feels like the right decision now and since you are where I want to be both length and girth wise I think it’s best I also listen to your experience and follow the same advice you’ve given.