To those who gained pumping

You do not have to answer all the questions - any help is fine.

1) To those who gained GIRTH:
- Were you packing the tube in all the areas in which you gained girth (i.e. if you gained midshaft girth, were you packing the tube at the midshaft?)
- Did you gain MORE girth where you were packing the tube than where you were not?
- Did pumping for many months/years eventually make the parts of your penis that were not packing initially eventually pack the tube?

2) To those who gained LENGTH:
- Did you gain length only after your penis was packing the tube for the most part, or did you gain length while much of the penis was still not packing?

Thanks for helping guys. I think if people answer some of these questions, we can help people figure out what kind of tubes they should be using for their goals (I know there is a thread on selecting cylinder size, but some anecdotal evidence never hurt anybody). Thanks again.

-Esc

If you are not packing your tube (whatever size) in the beginning and some time later you do because you gained, apparently it didn’t matter whether you packed or not.

I gained .5 inch Erect Length without fully packing the tube.

My experience is about the same as PErules. I pack only 1/4 of my cylinder and still have gained great length but 0 girth.