Girth

Is there such thing as to much girth?

I think so. It really depends on the partner, though. Having hit a max of 6.2” MSEG, I am now happily hovering around 5.8 or 5.9, and currently don’t want any more.

My primary motivation for being smaller is that I enjoy getting head.

When you start to resemble a “construction cone,” or bowling pin, you can surmise you have gone too far.

Anything over 5.5 and girls might start having problems.

I disagree, I have 6 and have had sex with several women and it was never a problem.

I think 6.5 is starting to top the limit, 7 being something else altogether.

Whom, I getting close to 6” Is it too much though?

Yes. Do a search, and look at some of the recent discussions about this.

6” seems to be the point where it starts to be something of a problem with a significant number of women, but as low as 5.5” a few women will have significant problems and some women will have minor problems.

For some perspective, 5.5” is about 90th percentile in girth, and 6” is about 95th percentile, definitely on the large side of what women are likely to encounter and their vaginas are likely to be intended to accomodate for intercourse.

FF

I agree with vagabond. I don’t know what women you guys are talking about. Has to be virgins or something because I have 6” girth and its not as big as you guys make it out to be.

6” girth is not big ? Then I wonder what YOU think is big ? 8” girth ? 9” girth ?

It is something that varies with each woman a lot. With my first wife when I was 5.2 MS-EG she would still bleed many times after sex even after 2 years of marriage, but now at 5.5 MS-EG I have been with a few women that I almost felt nothing from but at 5.5 I get a lot of “its thick” comments even though to me it doesn’t seem that thick until I look at something that is also 5.5 and realize it is pretty thick.

You hit the nail on the head. We find guys here like Vagabond who apparently haven’t run across a small vagina yet, and guys like you who have a lot of experience with them. Between my experience, and the sort of experience I see frequently enough from guys like you, GBB, it seems to me that there are a lot of smaller vaginas out there, and I know that I don’t want to get big enough that it’s going to be a problem particularly if Ms. Right turns out to be one of those women who are small. I think that ModestoMan has it about right from his experience of being a bit larger, that a girth a bit shy of 6” is about “ideal” for most guys who are going to have more partners and want the odds in their favor.

FF

As Tera Patrick once said:

“The bigger the better, the thicker, the wetter.”

While I think 6” girth is not big, its bigger than average though. Now when you get to 6.5”+ then you’re talking about the large. I consider myself one of the lucky ones only having to increase my girth by about .5-.75 for my final goal. As you guys know .25 increment girth increases are big differences and I once measured girths of different bottles from Lysol to shoe cleaners etc. and I know what really large girths look like. I’ve seen 8+ and never in my life would I want my dick that big otherwise the only girls that would have sex with you are the super freaks, which are very rare. Even the size queens would have second thoughts about that. I’ve thought about 7” girth as my final goal but from what I hear that would cross out the petite women and the “good girls”. Maybe when I get married I will consider going to 7” girth.

I think that 7” final goal is ideal for me because the women that I’m usually attracted to are size queens and I’d rather her say that I was to big than say I was to small

My erect girth is consistently 6-6.25”, depending on erection quality. I’ve had sex with four women since hitting the 6” mark. Two are very petite, 5’2” 105-115 pounds, both 27 years old. The other two are a little larger and in their forties. The petite ones have had a lot of trouble with the girth. One essentially can’t take it at all. The other is a submissive sexual freak who will take the pain to get the orgasm she says the thickness gives her. Both have cried on penetration, even after lots of foreplay and lube.

The other two have a lot less trouble with the thickness. In fact, both of the older ones have taken me anally, but neither of the young ones will even try. I should note that the older women have had 2-3 children, but only one of the young ones has a child and she was delivered Cesarean. So I think it really depends upon the woman, her experience level, and even how many children she has had. I don’t intend to stop seeking girth until I top 6.5”.