Many guys prefer the Starter. I’ve never used a full size Bib. My midshaft girth is a little under 5”, and I suspect the regular Bib wouldn’t adjust down small enough for me.
>The leading edge of the hanger that sets on or near the sides of the head was too narrow and sharp. What should I do to work around this problem?
Piet put tubing around the leading edge (shown here). Looks like a good solution.
> Also do you know if this hanger is comfortable with weight over ten pounds?
I never put in the ridges or did anything to fix the leading edge, so I don’t have any firsthand experience comparing it to a Bib. In my half-assed experiment of putting Bib hardware on pieces of flat PVC the problems were:
The sides weren’t rigid enough. This could be solved by using 2-3 layers on each side instead of only one.
The leading edge was narrow and uncomfortable. Again, 2-3 layers would make the sides (and edges) thicker. Or put tubing over it as Piet did.
Needed some ridges for gripping. Smooth plastic can’t grip the shaft very well. Piet solved this by bolting in strips of tubing.
With those issues resolved I don’t see why it wouldn’t be as comfortable as a production Bib. The Bibs have a cushy liner, but it isn’t necessary. The original Bib design didn’t have any padding. Bigger added it a the request of a beta tester. The liner isn’t very robust. Mine has torn again, and I’m about ready to rip it out. Dino removed his.