Well, he is entitled to his opinion. People have gained a good mile of Dick with the bib since Bib has been making it. Bib is the father of modern hanging techniques as we know them, has a track record longer than anyone currently practicing PE, and has made a tidy and fair business of selling his hangers as well as supporting each of his customers with any questions at his free hanging forums.
If this gentleman’s sales model includes denigrating the bib hanger as a part of how he persuades you to buy his product then he is a liar. The bib is the only proven hanging model I’ve seen and I have a
seen a LOT of PE gear.
While hanging is the oldest PE exercise and transcends written word about it, I doubt this gentleman created the Rosetta Stone of hanging at Home Depot. Give the hanger a try but don’t justify giving this hanger a try over the bib because the bib lacks something. The second part of that statement is simply not true.