Has anybody had permanent girth gains from pumping?

I am wondering if anyone has had permanent girth gains from pumping alone, or whether they had to incorporate another exercise like jelqing or clamping in order to get gains?

Probably continued pumping would secure gains, But it would prbably be best to do some jelqing to secure the gains, and even add to them.

PWPP: I got most of mine with jelquing and some pumping.

I think most of my girth gains are attributable to pumping. I started out at about 4.75 and now am around 5.5.

I’ve been pumping for about 10 years. I used to take maybe an hour to fill out a 1.75” tube. Now I pack it in about 5 minutes.

I wish I could get better length gains.

I go with mixing it all up. Pumping alone i believe will give gains but you’ll wait a long time before seeing them. I pump and jelq and have seen dramatic changes

I initially made good length gains but struggled to thicken out my rod. However I was in no rush for girth. My length gains have slowed down however in the last year its been my girth which has come along well. I started last year with 5.5” girth and am now I am around 6.1” -6.4” depending on EQ. My method uses primarily pumping and some jelqing.

Yes I’ve had permanent girth gains from pumping. My girth 12 years ago when I started was just over 3.0” my girth now flaccid is a steady5.0-5.25”. My erect girth is 5.75-6.0”. I do jelq after each pumping session. But now I’m using an extender hoping for more length.

That’s awesome!

And so is that!

I’ve gained substantial length and girth from pumping, but it took very many years.