Heck yeah
I am exactly 5.75” MSEG (Mid shaft erect girth) and 7.5” BPEL (bone pressed erect length). I am 49 years old. My whole life I have been on and off insecure about the size of my penis in spite of my experiences and now statistics telling me otherwise. I only tell you this because when asking a question with an answer that is really subjective, I believe knowing a persons state of mind allows you to better decide what their answer means to you. Having said that. Yes. I consider that big and most of the people that I know, consider that large, thick, or girthy. I know what the stats say now, but my opinion is based on my experiences. I have had sex or blow jobs from a total of 20 women in my life. Sex with 13. Blow jobs without vaginal sex with another 7. These are the results. 12/13 of the women I had vaginal sex with said I was anywhere from “big”, “really big”, “huge”,with one saying “monster”. The 1/13 actually said “you’re not small by any means, it’s just that my last boyfriend was absolutely massive”. I was both surprised to hear that and very damaged by hearing it. Insecurity came right back! For the blowjob-only-women, one didn’t comment at all about anything penis related. The other 6 said comments ranging from “bigger than average”, “big”, “really long”, and “you have a fat dick”. Four of them gave me a lot of teeth during bj’s. Three of them gagged often when trying to go to the bottom of my circ scar. Many of them said I was either the biggest or the thickest they had touched. It’s a decent sample size, so please use those reactions to decide for yourself, but I take them to be that “most” women would think 5.5” was “pretty thick” and the thickest or closest to the thickest she’s had. My first post ever so please be gentle with me if I made some errors or violated some guidelines. I know I wrote way too much. Sorry.