Dry vs. Wet Jelq

Just recently joined even though I have been reading the site for nearly a month. Does it seem to anyone that more uncircumcised guys prefer dry jelq vs. Wet and vice versa for the circumcised guys? I am circumcised and dry jelqing is very painful when I try it. Just seemed like something I noticed on the site, anyone notice more gains from one or the other?

I’m also circumcised, and I don’t do dry jelqs at all, just seems unnecessary to me. Wet jelqs are good and effective, whereas I think us cut guys have a lot more difficulty with dry jelqs than uncut guys, and a lot less effectiveness.

Just my 2 cents.

I’m uncircumcised and have gotten the most gains from wet jelqing.

I just didn’t find dry to be as effective. it felt like I was just moving the skin around and it didn’t give me the same “pump.”

Im circumcised and i feel more ‘moving’ inside with dry jelqs. Cant comment on the gains though.

I can’t comment on gains either, but I’m uncut and find that dry jelqing is much easier for me, especially since it’s low maintenance and doesn’t make a mess (my early attempts at wet jelqing with baby lotion were nothing short of disasters). Maybe I just hadn’t mastered it, but it definitely felt like my wang was too slick and I couldn’t get a good enough grip to move the blood inside.

But I couldn’t imagine dry jelqing without my foreskin. It definitely seems to act as a substitute for lubricant, much like it does during masturbation.

I’m circumsised and I only do dry Jelqs. No mess :) .

I’ve also made some gains, but we’ll see how it goes in the long run.

MYS

Hey, I was looking at the stats in your sig. What did you do to gain the 2” of girth ? I’ve been PEing for nearly a year now and have only managed 0.25” girth in that time.

Staying on topic. I only ever wet jelq, dry does not feel effective at all. I’m uncut (well my foreskin covers half of my head, I’m guessing that is a natural thing although I have never asked my parents if I was half circed at all)

I pull alot of skin up when Im jelqing dry so I always have to stop 1 inch before my glans, other then that its ok.

I’m cut too, so I don’t feel comfortable with dry jelq.

Hmm.from these responses I guess it’s not a cut vs. Uncut thing and more of just how much extra skin you have on your penis. With dry jelqing I just feel like I’m moving my skin all around lol.

I’m circumcised and do both. For me, I feel the wet jelq is more effective, because I can jelq the whole length of my penis up to the glans.

With a dry jelq it is more like an Uli for me; still effective but in a different way. I tend to do dry jelqs more as ‘jelq squeezes’.

My experience is almost identical to firegoat’s, with the difference that I am uncut.