Can length gains affect girth?

I guess this is it… quite simple but somehow logical I think - if I gain length it will be harder to gain girth since I’ll have more ‘space to fill’ with blood, right?

I’m asking this because I joined PE with mainly (totally) girth concerns… altough it’s 5.7” I really wish it was 7” and I’m gaining length pretty fast so I don’t know if I should back off with the stretching and only keep the jelqing or if I’m just saying bull. :P

Hope the vets have something to add ^^

The jury is out to you guys :)

Thank you

Well, the let’s say accepted logic here is reverse - attack length first, because ” a thin cable is easier to strech than a thick one “.
My advice - get to your length goals first, and then focus on girth.

If you have been consistent with the newbie routine, your 3 months should be up now, so you could slowly start to increase the intensity. That is if you feel that your dick has become conditioned enough.

From reading the general view appears to be gain length, then girth.

If you make something fatter first, then it clearly becomes harder to stretch.

If all you want to do is add girth, then go ahead, but I’d expect it to get more difficult to add length after that.

In reality most people target both to some degree. At 5.7” you are already well above average. I’m not sure if many or even any add almost 1.5” of girth, the general view is adding girth is much more difficult than length, and most feel adding 2” of length is very good to exceptional gains.

I also wonder why you want 7” girth? Try creating a shaft of this girth and sticking it in your mouth, what I’m saying is your probably at that girth going to make it impossible for you to get a blow job. You are also likely to hurt a girl during sex. Many guys at 6” or above report problems with blow jobs etc, read around.

I’m not being funny, but I wonder of the motives when a guy says he wants to be so big that he denies himself pleasure?

Your target is your target, but maybe you should research first. Regardless of length, the survey I saw says on a scale a-e, where a is ideal, at 7” girth girls would rate you a c, simply because your cause too much discomfort. Actually, believe it or not at 5.75 you are rated B, so actually by trying to gain that amount of girth, you may feel bigger, but girls in this survey regard you as worse than when you started!

6” girth is such a popular figure for a reason. 6-6.5” girth is rated as the best for pleasure in the survey I refer to, which not only looked at vaginal response, but also the physical response of girls.

Also, I have almost as much girth as length, that makes your cock look short and stubby and I’d say that regardless of size. If you were 7”x7” you will still look stubby. I’d much prefer a better balance of sizes than being equally loaded with girth and length, it just “looks” better. :) Dicks should be rectangular, not square!

This is interesting to me, because, even though I gained length from the start, I also added girth. In fact, the girth gains probably came easier than the length. Now, I seem to have reached a plateau and can’t get any length gains for anything. I don’t know if it has anything to do with early girth gains or not.

Getting enough blood should not be a problem. If it is, do some kegels.

Length gains should, technically, not hinder girth gains. As long as you can limit blood outflow (by jelqing, clamping, or whatever) you should be able to get enough pressure girth-wise.

I say “technically” because, as you gain length, you’re penis will be more conditioned which makes any gains more difficult. It may seem that the length gains stopped your girth gains but it’s probably just conditioning.

Hey ruz :)

So, what can I say… I had a 6.7” BPEL (now with less than a month of PE I’m at 7.1”) and 6.7” already caused me problems while having sex. No big deal but little problems (eventually I would hit the uterus of the girls in certain positions).
Girth, instead, already caused me the “problems” I wanted to (“Ow, it’s hurting a little but keep going…”), specially while doing anal.
I’m aware of the blowjob thing, a 6.5” should be very hard to swallow and to be honest, let’s see… if I hit this mark I will be very happy and already satisfied. :)

But the main thing is… length has caused me problems and girth not. I don’t know if it’s just this starvation of Brazilian girls for thick cocks but… I had “easy anal” with a couple of girls with 5.7” girth and that’s not what I want! :P
I want that little painful thing that, in the end, will cease to be painful and it’ll become only pleasurable.

Anyway I’ll take the advices of length being so much hard to gain once you have a fat penis and… let’s see. ^^

Thank you guys for answering, anybody who still want to answer, feel free to :)

Incidentally, the survey that Ruz_ linked to can be found at The Ideal Penis Size - The Penis Size Preference Chart: preferred penis size, penis shape and penis looks.. From that chart, you can see why the goal of most guys on this site is roughly 8x6 (I think that the ideal girth they show on the site is a bit high and the ideal length a bit low, but it’s still very close).

For me, at 6.75 BPEL and 5 EG, I’m much more interested in getting wider than longer, although both directions are welcome. From what I’ve read, however, it seems that girth gains without concomitant length gains are very rare, even when you’re focusing heavily on girth. That’s fine for me, but may not be the answer you’d hoped for.

You mean that you can only add girth while adding length?
It seems curious to me…

I have been through about every exercise anyone has come up with to gain girth including clamping. Here is the fun part, I started PE at about 6.75 length x 5 girth. After several years of on and off PE I am now 5.25 girth and have been struggling to gain any more. However, length has come very easy, I just measured at 8.125 length and still 5.25 girth, the last at least 1/4-1/2 inch of length has come exclusively from clamping. I started clamping to try to exclusively gain girth because I was happy with my length and have gained very little in girth yet continued to gain length.

Mine may be a rare case, I have 5-6 hours a day available to do PE for a few months and then have absolutely no opportunity (except the occasional bathroom stretch) for a few months. I suspect that if I was able to PE on a regular schedule my length would possibly level out and girth would increase at a more desirable rate, however, with this two months deconditioning/two months heavy exercise I feel that I am continually getting newbie length gains.

I read a while back that the site you guys linked is completely bogus. Just from looking at the chart it definitely seems that way (an 11x7” dick is enjoyable but a 5x5” is not)

Truth is the size benefits us more than them

I don’t know about anyone else but my girth gains just sort of came along for the ride. I didn’t find a need for deliberate work on girth It just sort of showed up.

Hu? I would have thought the above is an accurate statement?

The site, whether genuine or not, makes some valid points. It doesn’t entirely say bigger is better, and that also makes sense.

For example, 11”x7” is rated as “D”, 7 1/2 x 6 1/4 as “A”.

Guys think the bigger the better, but most girls you would have thought want a right size, not something to hurt them.

Whether you care about the site or your size is another matter entirely, but reading it it does seem to make some logical and valid points.

Ruz, the site is bullshit. The guy that owned the site even admitted to making up his own “results” after talking to a couple of girls he knew. Then he comes back later with a “survey” and expects people to swallow his crap again. Best to stay away from that dump.

I love that site, especially the scientific evidence and misogynistic rants. :)

penissizedebate.com is what inspired me to set up my phalloplasty fund (got it up to $4600 before finding this blasted forum). Now those were happy days.

Interesting JPPiz. I too feel that there is a difference between the PE habits that increase length vs girth — girth indeed seems to require consistency almost above all, whereas length in a sense seems to require the opposite to the extent that it stagnates if you are “too consistent”. This is probably an overstatement of the difference and it may even be totally wrong, but it’s consistent with my short PE career thus far.