The 3" Club

The question is, do you believe anyone who claims to be a member?

I know and have read of people gaining up to 4 inches. But golly, a 3” Club thread has already begun :(

Hmm, but do you believe someone who claims such a gain Okish6er? I kind of have a hard time doing so personally.

I think that DLD is the only one with those claims. Let’s be realistic, 3 inches…there is just not enough tissue to strech!

Well, there’s been a couple of others, none of whom posted start v finish pics as I recall.

I’m almost in the 2 inch club. I don’t see why 3 inches is a hard thought to grasp. Some hanging and pumping for me soon and I believe I can get there. But then again…I’m on steroids!

The thing is I’d love to believe it’s possible, but I really haven’t seen any evidence for it on here. I need three inches before I could ever call myself big. : (

What are your stats now ?

What do you mean by ‘stretch’? Penis is not a latex or gum-it does not have ‘once given’ amount of tissues that could be ‘stretched’ to ‘some limit’. Penis is constantly growing creating new tissues. Correct me if I am wrong :)

I also have trouble believing everyone who claims to have gained 3” but I do believe that theoretically such gains are possible.

It is possible but it will take A LOT of hard, HARD work. I’m sure that will make the lazy guys quit and us, more determined guys, to end up with the bigger dicks ;)

All things are possible. I think you would just have to learn what works for you, when it works and stay focused and dedicated on it. Alot of guys are dedicated and it does take YEARS. As far as what I believe, I think 3 inches is doable, it’s probably hell to get there, but it’s doable. There is nothing to indicate that PE is limited by some sort of biological maximum, as far as I know.

There are some liars here and there but I think that the vast majority of Thunder’s members are honest.

What about these guys YGuy, Bib, Jelktoid, RB? :)

I’d recommend that everyone interested in this subject take a look at the thread Size’s PE data analysis and a look at the graph datafit2-cool.jpg.

Is it possible to gain three or more inches? Based on the above, yes.

Is it likely? Based on the above, not very.

There are too many variables involved to be able to say for sure. Do gains slow or stop because of a biological limit, or due to lack of persistence? Did those who did not gain three inches stop because they decided that they had gained enough?

I believe that everyone has different potential, expressed in different ways. Some gain slowly, some gain more quickly. It’s not difficult for me to believe that some have more growth potential than others. I see this in terms of probabilities.

Your chances of gaining 1/2 inch: good.
One inch: pretty good
Two inches: fair
Three inches: less likely, with diminishing odds for additional size above that.

But surely in a group of this size, there’d be someone for whom too much was never enough. In that case, why aren’t we seeing more members with more than three inches increase? In another thread, I threw out the calculation that if you were able to gain a modest one millimeter per month, that would be 12 millimeters per year, or almost half an inch. Keep that modest rate up, and in five years, you’d have increased 60 millimeters, or more than 2.25"; in ten years, you’d be up by nearly 4.75". Has anyone actually achieved this? If not, why not?

I think persistence is likely the most important characteristic in achieving this plateau. I have been doing PE on and off for a few years now. Still hanging around 8 inches and a little. I did start at 6 and one eighth inches. Never really believed PE ever worked until I got to a little more than 7 inches, and even then I thought I was measuring wrong, that it must be because I lost weight or something. Well, I am a little older now, and a little weightier down there, but I am still around 8 inches. Still hang with the BIB, but not enough to work to a new level. For me, Bib and Jelqs were really all I did, perhaps they are all I ever will do. Anyways, I hope I can find the persistence as it sure would be nice to get to nearly 9 inches. They do say persistence pays.

All those folks are from the old days of the forum. I always thought there were a large number of guys back then claiming some stupendous gains. The gains of the few guys around in the early days seemed much more impressive than the gains of the many guys around these days. Simple statistics would suggest that, as the forum grows in membership, the number of 3 inch gainers would increase roughly proportionally. Instead, the number has gone down—in fact, nearly to zero.

One explanation is that the alleged big gainers from the early days were bullshitters. Maybe they were even bullshitting themselves. One cannot know. Another explanation is that they were especially dedicated. They were the pioneers of PE; not like us me-too folks. They put in the effort where those who came later gave up too soon.

Personally, I would never want to gain 3”; it would make my dick unmanageably huge and I think my wife would kick me out of bed. The fact that a 3” or more gain would take a guy beyond what’s really usable and fun to have (assuming he starts at near average size) is another reason I tend not to believe many of these claims. A sane person would give up at 1-2 inch gain (IMO).