The 3" Club

:)

I’m almost 6”, where can I join the double 3” club?

YGuy Progress Report(Copied from PE Forums)

There is a link to Y-guys documentation. I don’t remember if y-guy posted pics or not, I think so but won’t swear to it.

I know that Modesto Man has his doubts about some of the other guys, such as Bigger; I know Bigger personally, he and his wife. Biggers claims were true, he actually gained 4 inches; went from 6 inches to 10 inches in length, I don’t know about girth.

Bigger worked from home so he had lots of time to dedicate to PE and was able to gain a huge amount by anyone’s standards. And no, Bigger did not post pictures, he wanted to remain anonymous because of what he does for a living. We as members must respect that in someone, regardless of what they say they gained. Less skeptics are needed, especially when every claim of an inch or more is debated. How do you think that makes the guy feel who gained that inch or more? Would you want to have to defend every single gain you get? Post pics, sure, someone is gonna yell photo shopped, when they may not be. We need to take what is said at face value until such time as we can prove them wrong (see DLD). If someone is lying, they usually trip up and get caught.

There have been some really big gainers here over the years, those gains are documented. Stillwantmore had a huge flaccid (and yes, I knew him too), how much bigger that got erect is hard to say. I think alot of our pioneers left because they got sick and tired of having to defend every word that came out of their mouths to the "non-believers" of the board. And it wasn’t that the "non-believers" didn’t think PE would work, they didn’t believe what our gainers were saying.

Think about how you would feel if you had to defend every little thing you said here.

Wise words…

I have only 1/2 inch to go to reach the 3.00 inch mark, I’m hoping to have it by the end of this year.

Here you go,

My Comparison Pics

Y-Guy’s story always seemed to me to have a ring of truth. His comparison pics are convincing even though they start out at 7”.

He wasn’t selling anything and didn’t seem to have any reason to say he started smaller that he did. He is one of the few whose gains I

actually believe. He just came across as a honest guy, or maybe I’m just really gullible?

If you are, then so am I. I share the same impressions of YGuy.

Yep I couldn’t remember if he had pictures but was going to post the same as Ive read his threads before now.

Only problem with the pictures is they only show a rough gain rather then massive gains he no doubt actually got. Still it has to be one of the most compelling cases in the TP archives.

Also I would say similar of Bib though their would be far more reasons to base doubt on

Said ever thing sunshinekid. Some guys has to realize that we are here to made gains for ourselves (wife’s, GF, some bitch that say you have small) not to prove or disprove that PE it’s possible, I made my modest newbie gains, some may believe and some not but the most important person for me believe and that’s it, I think it’s possible to gain 3” or maybe more, see the bennet8 photos the guy has really change his penis at all.

Did you saw Biggers cock?

No simon I did not see it, but I did talk face to face with Mrs. Bib (Bigger). Why would she lie to me? I have said all I am going to here. I will not justify every word I say, either you take it at face value or you don’t.

I have to admit that I’ve never cross-referenced those dates/posts/measurements, etc. So, I’ll take you at your word on that. I certainly don’t claim to *know* that those guys did or did not achieve their gains, I was only noting my “gut impressions” about them (however, I’m referring to RB & YGuy - not Bib).

Regarding your statements that RB, YGuy & Bib made most of their gains before coming to Thunders…. well, so did I.

I found my first routine online - a freebie. Then I stumbled upon “Cheeky Cherry” for a few months, and was eventually (I admit with shame) suckered into buying the WORTHLESS “Penis Advantage” pay guide.

I didn’t find Thunder’s until after I’d gained > 1”. Since I’ve just barely gained 2” EL (altogether), then you probably would place me into that same cynical, categorical conclusion: Thundersplace membership prevented me from having big gains.

I think its easy to regard the reported gains of others in relation to our own personal experiences. Those who’ve made easy gains, tend to be more believing of the good reports of others. Those at the other end of the spectrum, who’ve made little if any gains, tend to disbelieve anybody reporting good gains. (I saw this with weight training as well…guys who made decent gains were willing to believe that I was drug-free [and I was]; but the guys who couldn’t gain shit were convinced that I was juicing).

I had not reached the “2 Inch Club” for a long time (almost 5 yrs of on-off PE), but after I began mem’s routine, I got some quick gains before I quit because of other circumstances. Based on my existing elasticity levels (still a major grower) and the effectiveness of mem’s intense routine, I believe that I have a gambler’s chance of possibly hitting the “3 Inch Club” - if I could ever string together 12-18 months of dedicated PE.

In no way do I believe that 3” EL gains are “impossible.” I would say extremely rare - for many of the reasons already mentioned in this forum - but not impossible.

Furthermore, none of us is scientifically qualified to say which gains are possible or not. Obviously, I’d never believe somebody making really outlandish claims, but 3” EL gains are not “outlandish.”

I have never doubted your gains, Wad, in part because you’ve been so good at being a cynic yourself and revealing the false claims of others.

My point is simply this: Thundersplace has been up and running for 5 or 6 years now. Still, there has not been a single person (to my knowledge) who has reported a 3” gain during his time here at the forum. Given the huge number of members here and the relatively small number of PE’ers in the early days before Thundersplace, the current lack of 3” gainers strikes me as very odd.

If I can get off my lazy ass I will run some numbers. Tube showed a long time ago that the average gains from PE were a little less than an inch. We need to look at the numbers from Size’s database and compute a distrubution of gains. Given the general shape of the distribution, one can estimate the standard deviation. From that number (assuming normal distribution), one can predict the frequency of 3” gainers.

I think that will give us a better idea of how reasonable the various claims are.

I know that relatively few guys hit the 2” club, and I’d always assumed that most guys probably gain about an inch or so. But I think that the psychological factors involved might be almost as relavant as the physiological.

As we progress, not only do gains become tougher, but our desire also flags because of the very gains that we’ve made; and further gains become exponentially tougher. This is a very real factor - it starkly happened to me also

When viewing the data, it will be tough to know where the physiological limits blend with the psychological “limits.”

There could be some possibility to the notion that the early pioneers of PE really were fanatical - to have gone so far as to bring this to the internet, push the workouts very hard (often with limited information), etc.

I know that at one weight club I trained at years ago - a small gym in a small town - we had a disproportionately high number of real animals. The 300-lb benchers probably 98% (almost everybody, lol), 350 at maybe 50% and 400 at maybe 20% (you’d find nowhere near those %’s in a huge gym).

But, it’s probably something we’ll never really know.