I don’t want to scatter everyone’s attention, so rather than posting a link I’ve condensed a previous thread and included separate links to the individual posts (in an effort to keep everyone on-topic in this thread)
The clearest information I’ve been able to find at LPSG (admittedly I didn’t look very far) on what’s considered big: 8 inches is considered big. An 8 inch penis normally has a 5.5 inch girth, anything over 5.5 inches girth is considered big.
Info from the Channel 4 documentary “The Perfect Penis”:
Dr. John D. Moran (A consultant in sexual medicine)
Stated that average penis size is between 5 and 7 inches (i.e. average size is 6 inches)
He also said:
“an ‘extra large’ penis can cause more problems than benefits (presumably extra large is “anything over 8 or 9 inches”)
He went on to say:
“I think in terms of length anything over 8 or 9 inches could perhaps cause a problem. For instance the average length of the vagina is probably more like 5 or 6 inches, so that could be a problem but the girth of the penis is even more relevant, I think, in terms of perhaps causing a problem for penetration.”
Dan (A 25 year old college graduate from L.A.)
Length 8.5 inches
Dan said “There’s definitely a negative consequences to having too much length and not being able to fully penetrate a woman”
He goes on to say that women tend not to like it because there’s no pelvic stimulation and so for him sex becomes like a chore. The documentary also stated that he’s been “forced” to use the large penis support group to find women.
Lennie & Lesley (A married couple from South Carolina.)
Lennie’s length is 8 inches
Lesley stated that she loved having a man with a large penis and that she couldn’t get her hand all the way around the base of Lennie’s. She also said that she had friends who had partners with large penises and that they’d often wish they didn’t have to have sex, and hoped that the guy would ‘come quickly’.
She said that the first time she had sex with Lennie that she had thought “Oh boy what am I gonna do with this. Am I gonna get hurt by this?”
She also said “I don’t think that there’s anything that’s shut off as far as sexually; there are things that are more difficult”
Omar (A U.K. Porn-star)
Length 11 inches
Omar stated that “bigger is better” in terms of what’s better for making porn. He also said that in his private life women “either love it or hate it” and that women have “put off” having sex because it’s hurt them.
Originally Posted by Peter Dick
I have stopped working length just for the same reason. You will bottom out in most women with 8” NBP.
I was bottoming out in 50% of all women with a 7.25” NBP length.Peter Dick - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by rednuht
Im 8.5x6inch bone pressed.My wife is 5.2 at 110 lbs.She has no problem.rednuht - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by Titleist
I’m at 6.5-.75 in girth and right at 8.0 in length. I’ve had more problems with length than anything else. I find that arousal level and the time of month dictate if I can go all the in or not […] I would think that 7.5 in girth would present some challenges, but then again who knows.Titleist - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by Dino9X7
At 8.5bp I can hit bottom pretty easy now and have to be careful I think anything more would be silly but I’m still trying for 9bp max because I’m a f-ing silly bastard.Dino9X7 - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by Endow, swensk, AndroNYC,
Originally Posted by Endow
So going off what has been said so far, it seems as though the ever-famous 8x6 measurement defends it’s title as “the perfect unit”.However, with some girls this may be too much and additional expansion (via additional foreplay) would be required if you want to go “balls deep”. With the few girls that would be exceptions, it seems as though 8.5x6 would then really be pushing it (as if it wasn’t already being pushed enough) and even with much expansion this would then be beyond the maximum in the great majority if women (95%+?). It seems as though it would be safe to say that anything over this would be ridiculous as even if the girl is really expanded (which would already require ‘more than average foreplay’, to say the least), she simply wouldn’t be able to take the whole thing.
Again, 8x6 seems to be the max that the great majority of women can take (95%+?). With the few exceptions that it wouldn’t (~4%?), it seems as though 8.5x6 is then the max. Beyond 8.5x6, and you’d have to hope that you have some rare woman who can actually take more, especially “balls deep” (1%?)
So… it breaks down like this then, according to consensus in not only this thread, but many other threads I’ve read on this same topic:
95% of women would have a max of 8x6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
4% of women would have a max of 8.5 x 6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
1% of women would have a max of over 8.5 x 6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)… keep in mind that the very few women who actually have a max beyond that measurement, which would only be relevant with only 1% of women, could just as easily have a max of 9x6.
If I was to actually record this it’d likely then look something like:
.5% = a max of 9x6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
.3% = a max of 9.5 x 6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
.15% = a max of 10 x 6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
.05% = a max of anything over 10 x 6 (give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most)
Endow - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by Swensk
Not that I don’t believe you, but where did you find this info Endow? What/which thread(s)?I think that girth for 95% could be raised a bit higher, like 6.25 or something. It is the length that hurts primarily.
Swensk - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by androNYC
Endow- without even addressing the ‘validity’ [not meaning to call it into question- irrelevant to my point], I don’t know that I give much weight to any such ‘survey’- they aren’t in any way ‘controlled’- by their nature they really can’t be.androNYC - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by Endow
Also, to AndroNYC (and indirectly to the others that read this thread) […] the information stated is from many many many many months of reading on this site, and from years of well, being alive :p . I’ve searched the topic, read just about every damn thread started about it on this site, and that is in-part how I came up with those statistics. After I posted it, I even whipped out a calculator and they still seemed to match up with the probability factor. Remember, these aren’t surveys, these are from real accounts that people have experienced. There’s no reason to lie about it on here, and I can smell bullsh*t from a mile away if somebody was to try to lie about it in front of me in real life. I’ve known a lot of people - I wouldn’t put out statistics like that if I didn’t truly feel that they represented the real-world.I do agree with you though Swensk that the girth max may be raised a little higher, such as to the 6.25 that you mentioned. Though that is why after all EG measurements I put in ( ) ‘s “give or take 1/4-1/2” girth at most).
Endow - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery
Originally Posted by androNYC
Endow-
I had cast no aspersions on your data’s accuracy- I don’t agree with the basis of the data nor with premise it is used to support. That’s all.
I think it’s one of those murky areas of opinion that can’t really be settled with any authority.androNYC - The Size at which a Penis is Too Big: Info from 3rd Channel 4 Documantery