Erect Hanging

I don’t understand the negative attitude toward erect hanging. I think it is because we believe that the addition of longitudinal tension to the large pressures already inflating the corpora would be too risky. I do understand this criticism of erect hanging somewhat but not really from a technical standpoint.

What I would REALLY like to know is why isn’t it acceptable to hang unusually light weights from an erect penis; say for instance hang one pound. I guess since I have never tried it I don’t understand what problems I might face.

One advantage of this technique would be a decrease in stress on the skin and ultimately decreased skin soreness.

Can any experts comment in more detail on erect hanging?

Thanks,
Tube

I had something happen to me the other night that I found interesting and maybe relevant. I was hanging SO while on the computer and a female friend who loves to talk dirty to me came online. While hanging she got me going pretty good. I always do a flacid stretch measurement after a hanging session and on this particular occasion I was a full 1/4” longer than normal. I’m not advocating the theory but it is intriguing.

Tube,

Hanging while erect will create a two force situation, in which the stresses will increase the risk of injury. As an example, it is very hard to pop a deflated balloon.

But the biggest question is why would you want to take this risk? It is proven that flaccid hanging can create gains without the risk.

Bigger

Hmmmm,

The well known image of a balloon popping catastrophically into floppy fragments of balloon shell is certainly a scary image when you make the analogy to your own erect penis. We could discuss the utility of this analogy and compare and contrast the physical issues involved in each situation; however, that is not really what I want to do right now.

You obviously have a ton more experience than me Bib, and you are certainly at the level of a grandmaster hanger, whereas I am still in my infancy. However, you certainly would admit that an erection is itself not dangerous. You would also probably agree that hanging an ounce of weight from your erect member is also not dangerous. At what point does it become dangerous? As you gradually add more and more weight how do the stresses in tunica increase? As long as the stresses develop in a well behaved smoothly varying fashion, there should be some optimal weight which is both safe and effective.

People do not hang 50 lbs off their flaccid penises. That would be dangerous. Likewise erect hanging is dangerous at some levels.

There are indeed reasons why I am asking these questions. If hanging 1 lb in an erect penis is as effective and safe as hanging 5 lbs in a flaccid state, then which is better? The one lb erect hang requires less compressive force from the hanging device than does hanging 5 lbs in a flaccid state. This may lessen the burden on the skin and reduce skin stretch.

Come to think of it, maybe I am asking the very question I didn’t think I wanted to address. How exactly do the stresses develop in a high pressure chamber under tensile forces? And how does this differ from the stresses in a low pressure chamber under a higher tensile force? Furthermore, is the analogy to a balloon a useful one? This problem is on my to-do list. I am not advocating anyone do erect hanging until A) a thorough analysis of the mechanics of high pressure stretching is carried out, and B) an expert hanger tries it out and gives the green light.

People do after all perform erect bends. I find it curious that these same “extreme PE’ers” do not advocate erect hanging.

-Tube

Tube,

>People do after all perform erect bends. I find it curious that these same “extreme PE’ers” do not advocate erect hanging. <

I’m not going to address the other questions/comments in your post, (not even the ones I understood). You won’t EVER hear a vet or an experienced PE’er advocating erect hanging. *Maybe* YOU, with your high pressure tensile and physics degree or whatever could find a way to hang erect (I said maybe), but you can be sure it is still fucking dangerous. And what about the 5000 lurkers reading who don’t have the knowledge or experience to even be thinking about such an endeavour, even *if* it was possible?

In the PE world, the latest ‘fad’ spreads like wildfire, and with all the newbies looking for the magic bullet (PE pills are still good business right?), there will be tears, I assure you. I for one don’t want that one my conscience!

I don’t think that anyone should try this, not even you, physics-boy.

There was a member on the old board called ForgedCrank, who hung partially erect. Not even fully erect, and he cause a serious tear in the tunica, which had to be repaired surgically.

Stay safe kids - only hang flaccid.

Stay in school.

Don’t do drugs.

Enjoy Coke.

SS4

Stay safe kids - only hang flaccid.

Stay in school.

Don’t do drugs.

Enjoy Coke.

Listen to SS4

Kinda contradictory there ey Capn?

Tube,

>However, you certainly would admit that an erection is itself not dangerous. You would also probably agree that hanging an ounce of weight from your erect member is also not dangerous. At what point does it become dangerous? As you gradually add more and more weight how do the stresses in tunica increase? As long as the stresses develop in a well behaved smoothly varying fashion, there should be some optimal weight which is both safe and effective.<

I am sure you are correct. The problem comes with the exponential nature of exerting two forces on an object. As the forces are increased, the stresses on the whole are greater than the sum of the individual forces. Therefore, it is much easier to reach a point of maiming stress, without ever putting that much force into it.

SS4 mentioned Forgedcrank. He did not even realize what had happened until he took the noose off of his penis.

>Furthermore, is the analogy to a balloon a useful one?<

Probably not, other than a popping balloon approximates the same two force stresses that erect hanging would provide.

>People do after all perform erect bends. I find it curious that these same “extreme PE’ers” do not advocate erect hanging.<

Several erect benders have experienced tragic problems also. Joe seven comes to mind.

Bigger

Oh, I do. I think Tube should be the one to try it instead of posing theoretical questions. Discussions about things like this mean very little until someone actually tries it. SS4 suggests it might be newbies who try and I agree. That wouldn’t really be fair to make someone who doesn’t know any better try something that might hurt them. It should be a guy with some experience than none.

Go for it Tube!

Wrestler,

>Discussions about things like this mean very little until someone actually tries it.<

Hmm, I’m sure someone has ForgedCrank’s email address…why not try telling him that?

SS4

SS4 makes some sobering points. I also do not want anyone to try it, so don’t. I just wanted to put my ideas on some paper and toss it around a little bit. Anyone who reads this needs to understand where I am coming from. I like to think and speculate and hypothesize and that is all this is. If I were to ever take this to the experimental level I would do it very slowly. I am a very cautious person by nature, especially when there is the possibility of destroying my penis for life. I would start hanging at about 10% of my flaccid hang weight and stay at that weight for about a week and see how things go. Then I would move up to 20%. Since I don’t have any time to devote to analyzing this any more right now I’m not going to be trying it. Plus, I am not even convinced there would be much benefit to the technique. Perhaps it would reduce the discomfort many experience on their skin. But thats not much for risking your peepee’s functionality. If I were going to start analyzing this I would start with analyzing the internal forces in 2-dimensional membranes, then figuring out how a tensile force changes things. All in all, Its a scary dangerous thing as the experts have already pointed out. Its kind of like an in the back of my mind type thing that might eventually progress to an experiment but only after a lot of paperwork and analysis. Maybe in a few months.

Thats all for now,
Tube

/forum/search.p hp?s=&action=sh … rder=descending