Are you supposed to get temp immediate gains with jelqing

Just to be clear I am not asking whether jelqing gains are permanent.

What I want to know is whether I should expect temporary gains immediately after jelqing, similar to how people experience after pumping.

I am currently not getting any temp gains from jelqing. Does this mean I should jelq a little harder?

Also when I used the bathmate I didn’t get any temp gains either and I pumped pretty hard. Maybe it’s because I’m a newb or maybe it’s because penises are different?

Do you warm up?

I jelq in the shower, so I warm up by running very warm water on my penis for a few minutes.

You should check out the rice sock warm up. At the beginning of the week I used a shower/bath to warm up, read about the rice sock, and now that’s my favorite way to warm up. It’s very effective and VERY pleasant.

But out of curiosity, how many jelqs are you doing? The Newbie Routine shows me temporary gains after jelqing, so that might also be a consideration.

I never got temporary gains as such from jelqing - sometimes but not always I got better flaccid hang. But never anything like the ‘bloating’ you can get from fluid buildup after pumping.

Does the warm up play a role in achieving temp gains? Why are people focusing on the warm up?

Warming helps expansion.

So one should not worry about this?

I just re-read some of the beginner FAQ on here and it mentions the same thing,
"Your dick should feel & look fuller for several hours after jelqing”

I have been using a homemade power-jelq device (can opener) and also manual jelqs on my guy for about a week now, with an off day or two ..

My dick does hang slightly fuller after putting it in the hot water cup for my warm up, but it definitely has *never* been bigger after jelqing. Never at all.

I’m also slightly worried that I may be over-doing it for a newbie.

I can sit down and watch porn for 30 or 40 minutes while alternating between jelqing and then a minute to a few minutes of jerking my limp dick to get it back in to the right range.

I have a horrible time staying semi-erect with no real stimulation. I practically need the constant feel of a vagina on my dick to stay hard, so I wouldn’t say I spend 45 minutes jelqing .. But it’s definitely more than 15.

I will keep trying to monitor my EQ over the next few days\weeks .. But I’m not sure if I should cut back or just keep plowing ahead. I still get boners in the morning, which is nothing new. But they aren’t any harder or more often than normal, far as I can tell. Aren’t any worse either. My dick doesn’t feel raw, or hurt, or nothin’. I think the soreness I felt the first few times using the power-jelq was just my dick unaccustomed to the type of friction the insulation-tubing provided. (Also maybe hair being irritated, which I have sense manscaped) ..

So no worries about not being fuller after a jelq session then?

No, no worries. And yes, it does sound like you are over-doing it. Maybe try the linear newbie routine. And dump the power jelqer for now!