Manual vs mechanical jelqs

I will be switching to a girth focused routine in a couple months at my one year PE mark. I have read many post on girth routines, sore hands, grip, etc. My question is if anyone has done jelqs manually as well as mechanically (mason jar gripper)? Is one more beneficial and what direction (grip sides or top/bottom) worked with gripper?

It’s been a long time since I saw anyone using a jelq device, seems they’re not popular.
There are a few old threads about them if you search but the consensus is usually stick to using your hands.

There is nothing that can beat your own 2 hands for jelqing.

I have read the old threads but was hoping someone had tried both for a comparison. Nothing like a solid opinion from someone capable of gaining girth and comparing pros/cons of each type.

In my experience, jelqing can’t compete with mechanical methods such as clamping and hanging. I’ve tried most of the jelqing devices, and I’ve found that jelqing creates pressure only for each stroke, which may be seconds at best. Clamping can create pressure for 10 whole minutes versus a small handful of seconds per session for jelqing. I gained .75” in girth in 6 months with clamping and I was being lazy. Sustained pressure over time is what promotes growth. Clamping is infamous for massive girth gains, but like any exercise it can be dangerous. Don’t try clamping unless you have some experience with PE for awhile. Just my 2 cents.

I’ve always wondered that, if the goal is to pump blood into the corpora cavernosa and stretch the tissues, WHY jelqing if we can just clamp or pump?
Also, how does pumping compare to clamping? I want to get greater girth and a mighty EQ, after some experience with jelqing and stretching I decided to just stretch and pump, because jelqing is too boring haha, and I never clamped (I feel I’m not yet trained enough for it)

Could you guys explain to me the differences between both jelqs?

Thanks

Hi, there is a significant difference between pumping and clamping. Pumping draws blood and lymph into the internals of the penis and by extension, under the skin.. Causing fluid build up and mostly temporary gains unless done very often which can force the person to seclude themselves for long periods. Clamping uses the force of blood pressure to expand the tissues from the outside only. I know I’m missing a few items in regards to pumping (research the site), but, Clamping is far more efficient compared to pumping but is also more dangerous to a new penis. The results gained from clamping create effects similar to extended priapism, which has been medically documented to increase penis girth and length over time. Permanent results are well documented for clamping versus pumping which is for the most part temporary and requires much more time for similar gains. I’ve tried both and got almost nothing out of pumping for extended periods, so that is why I favor clamping along with many other vets on this site. Hope that helps.

Clamping and pumping are not the subjects of this thread. There are other threads comparing them, read them M8ter you could learn something.

I believe I’ve learned enough to discontinue helping people via corresponding through these elaborate threads and simply let my results speak for themselves. If they want to learn more about my techniques, they can follow my progress reports.

If you wanted to help people in these “elaborate threads”, you’d probably stick to discussing the intended topic. In this case, Manual vs mechanical jelqs.

Haha haha They’re discussing menopause and weight lifting on the “Is showing a bulge offensive” thread. Better run right over and piss on their parade too boys. Considering that some of these threads can go for possibly hundreds of pages and go off on tangents multiple times, yeah I would consider that elaborate. I’m out.

A few notes:

- extended priapism is also medically documented to permanently damage the penis and result in permanent ED. I do believe that longer duration very hard erections are very useful in PE, but that’s controlled and not like priapism at all.

- there are many vets here who have made significant permanent gains with pumping. The protocols here minimize edema. Routines are typically between 30 mins and an hour. Does not require long term seclusion. Many guys do other stuff while they pump: wash dishes, read a book, watch the news on TV

- clamping may (or may not) result in quicker gains than pumping. But as you note pumping is a gentler exercise. Additionally some guys have experience the opposite of what you’ve experienced: no gains with clamping, gains with pumping. In my case clamping destroyed my EQ. Regular pumping improves my everyday EQ.

I guess long story short is some methods work for some guys and don’t work for others. Pumping didn’t work for you, clamping didn’t work for me.

+

Always choose the safest method to obtain gains.

Thanks man. In my eagerness to help people I’ve been offering advice using only my experiences and I shouldn’t. Everyone responds differently to the routines. The key to PE really is tissue breakdown and repair, which can be achieved in many different ways. I need to allow people to make the decision to seek out my advise and not force it on others.