4thewind,
I think you’ve given manual exercises a valiant effort, but you know what they say about trying the same thing repeatedly without results (it’s the textbook definition of “the crazies”). I’m not trying to call you insane; What I am suggesting is: is that you change it up, and if you are dedicated enough maybe take some added risk.
I’m in the same boat as you on girth measurements 4.5 which is on the shallow end of average, and I do not think many people who frequent this forum give the deviation between a 4.5 and a 5 any thought when it comes to growth factors and physiological preconditions that effect a routines success. I myself have tried a dedicated 3 - 4 month manual routine with no noticeable results. Unfortunately it seems to be the case that men with thin penises ( and I define that as any man under 5” base girth) have a much greater challenge at achieving girth gains simply because our bodies and tendons/ ligs in particular are not designed to sustain that much tissue; Also thin PE beginner would have to achieve an amazing 50% volume increase all in girth from say about 10 cubic inches (based on 4.5g X 61/4”L) to increase their girth to the “big-average” realm of 5.4” (about the size of a cardboard spool for TP). That’s WITHOUT any length. Whereas a man with a 5.0 girth and similar length only has to increase his volume by 20% to achieve the same goal. This means that you are at the very least going to have to grow 2.5 times more than Mr. 5 incher.
I think you also have to start looking at and learning about your physiology, metabolism, hell even family history. Is you muscle mass very tight and sinewy, but small in size? Do you eat alot and not put on weight (could be high metabolism or malabsorbtion of nutrients or both)? Is your full erection very rigid or does it give a little under your grip? What angle is your LOT? Etc.Etc..
The ease with which your entire body is affected by conditioning (diet/ execrise/ or conversely overeating and sedentary) very likely correlates with the way stresses will
Affect your genitals. Many people tend to take an approach to PE which does not recognise that your penis is a part of the rest of your body and has the same genetic predispositions and unique response to stress. We suppose that the same method which added two inches L and an inch of G to the guy that was a 7 ” X 5.5” to begin with and also happens to be a large bodybuilder who was star QB in high school and has a 1200 Testosterone count should work for us..
Possible? Yes. Maybe even likely. But if it doesn’t work after 6 to 9 months of dedication and tweaks here and there. It ain’t happenin’. And I don’t want to try and create a schism, when support and coaching is concerned, between the people who started big and got bigger or those who have stirsticks for dicks like me and haven’t gained a hair. I do, however, think unsuccessful PEers need to stop beating themselves up when the vets and easy gainers insist that they are performing the fundamental exercises incorrectly because they worked for them. There are only so many combinations of incorrectly manipulating and warming your wang to exhaust before doing them right (part of the beauty of the workouts is their simplicity and the fact that you can DL video of them clearly being done).
As for solutions to your (our) problem. I think you should start exploring combinations of more intense methods. Get a bib hanger going, or fiddle with similar warehouse materials until you come up with a harness that’s is comfortable (AND SAFE! No noose.). I’ve dabbled in hanging; Got up to twelve pounds for 10 min increments. Got lazy with it after bout 3 weeks (obviously not enough), but did notice a soreness deep in the penis similar to DOMS that felt on the right track somehow. Anyhow I never got that feeling from manual work no matter how hard soft of long I stretched. The trick with hanging is to find the position where there is an equallibrium of pull on the skin around the base ligs and pressure on the glans (with less pressure on the glans and none if possible though I have not figured that part out). There will be intense and sometimes painful sensation (especially when the skin is taught). You can alleviate tension by repositioning while seated and edging or bending of the lowerback while standing. You have gone too far or have wrapped incorrectly when you feel pinching at the glans, sudden sharp pain, or the glans is deep purple (red purple OK the blue tones or pale yellow with numbness denotes a lack of oxygen to tissues and or capillaries are bursting. Always make it extremely easy to release tension. I didn’t even mess around unclasping the caribeaner. I fastened a leash to the weight and immediately tugged up at the first sign of odd feeling; then unhooked.
I’m a pretty regular clamper. But have not gone to intense and have not seen permanent gains. I will say that while clamped the engorged feeling is great and once flaccid it is much larger for a long duration. At the next erection, however, no gains.. So far. Maybe you do have to go at it until there is discoloration; Haven’t worked up the nerve yet. I still think it is a key exercise in girth gains, but there is could be a connection with initial base girth and how much it will benefit. I am 4.5”g at the base when skin is stretched back and slightly thicker at top (with a mighty 5.5” rim on my glans; very top heavy). Many people report great base gains with hanging and conversely clampers report girth throughout the shaft. Maybe by combining the two you can get a better swelling effect in the shaft from clamping on the added base girth.
After a hanging / clamp routine (and yes lets not forget at least 5 -10 mins warm wrap + manual stretching warm up (which I know to be vital but often forget) If you do not see any gains from that alone you may try an ADS post workout (home made of course. Do not waste money buying one. I’ve done it twice and it isn’t necessary). Use a small dowel style wrap (that applies very little pressure to the -SIDES- NOT dorsal/ ventral of the shaft near the glans.. Basically replicate the hanging apparatus but instead use an ELASTIC length of string and tie the other end loosely below one knee.. Rig the string so it has a clamping adjuster for tightening (like the draw string off a hoody sweater). The tension should be so light that you could potentially sleep in it without noticing. A cold glans is okay. A numb one is not. The theory behind wearing this device post work out (and it is a sound theory) is so the elastic collagen fibers repair in a desirable way. Pretend you are lame enough to play the accordion and one day your dog gets one end of it and you play tugowar.. Parts of the accordion tear open but it doesn’t break in two. If you used glue to repair it would you compress it all the way and start pouring glue all over OR would you stretch it out and glue? You’d stretch it out so it doesn’t get stuck shut.. Penis.. Same thing. Collagen latices fill in gaps in the super structure of the ligs and tendons like spider webbing. Over time the process repeats, elasticity potential decreases, while load bearing and mass increases. It isn’t theory. Thats why Schwartzenager spent 2 hours swimming and doing ballet for every hour he spent pumping. He new to stretch gently.
Other angles to incorporate: Why just warm up at the beginning of the workout? Get an in-fared light (heat lamp) and position it in front of your goods while your hanging / clamping or hell sleeping if you can figure it out. Just don’t let the fireman recover your charred body in the middle of some PE ritual. “I.. I think it’s an ADS device sir.” “A what?”.. “Never mind sir.” Different types of light stimulate the natural world on a cellular level in amazing ways and I don’t doubt it has positive affects on the inflammation process in humans.
Consider supplements: Creatine, L Argine, NO2, Glutamine, Saw Palmeto, Multivitamin, Collagen or some combo of. NO PE PILLS NOT EVEN TO SUPPLEMENT> SCAM SCAM SCAM!
What else?. Safely but strategically maintain a muscle confusion style regiment. Vary your routine as soon as you hit a plateau. Not working. Give it two to Three months and move on. When hanging spend some time lowering the weight before increasing. Gently stretch and bend while clamping.
I guess the summary is: make it a hobby don’t lose sight of the goal but don’t focus on it. Take the journey.
Well that was probably the most advice from someone with no gains but it helps keep me motivated to get all my unused knowledge out. It isn’t the end of your PE journey when Manual doesn’t work. Many vets preach and swear by them, but there are those who can never and will never gain from them even if the have a personal trainer helping them with reps (ewww). Don’t throw them out completely, but don’t rely on them.
-Stirstick
And I’m spent.