I’ve tried more is more and it didn’t work as well as I was hoping. I literally used to hang all day every day (one day off a week) competing with myself to get the most sets into each day, to get to what I thought wasthe sweet-spot for gains reported by the heavy hangers.
Part of the thinking behind my routine was to actually consciously condition my unit to take heavier and heavier weight so that I could get into the envelope where, reputedly, gains would accelerate.
I broke my hanger trying to hang just a fraction of the weight claimed by the old-school heavy-hangers. I even had to resort to using a carpenter’s d-clamp to attach the hanger just to be able to hang about half of the weight that was suggested for optimum gain.
Even when I plateaued I still persisted in hanging, way past the point of diminished returns, basically because I wanted to get it over and done with once and for all, so that I could get on with my life. After about three months of no further gains I just came to consider those three months a maintenance/’cementing’ routine and gave up entirely. When I started I only saw the idea of less is more posted by one guy who virtually nobody paid any attention to. He said he was getting consistent gains with what seemed like barely any exercise and, at the time, it sounded ludicrous.
Having taken a long long time off I’m back for the last half-inch and I’m starting with the ‘new newbie / Linear’ routine (NEW newbie + advanced routine) at the lowest intensity it describes (I’ve just done a few heavy-duty, multiple method days but having read about this new approach I’m cutting right back to a starting point of twenty jelqs every other day), basically because I want to spend as little time and effort as possible in getting the last half-inch, and I want to know more accurately my best potential for future gains in case I want to get even larger, and by spending this little time at the beginning of my return to P.E. it should, in the long run, save me a lot of time that would otherwise be spent on over-training and decon breaks. A lot of the problem with non-gainers could very well be lack of patience (and lack of discipline). I used to way too impatient and, because I really believed that gains had to be hard won, I think I probably pushed myself much too hard. Now that I’m able to jelq, and, having seriously committed myself to a newbie routine for the first time I can see just how much of it was to do with my attitude towards the process.
When I first began P.E. I was unwell, and not strong enough do manual exercises, so I went straight to Penimaster and then to a hanger and then on to (what now seems to be) a ridiculously intensive hanging regime, basically because it seemed like minimum effort for maximum gains— after all I only had to attach the equipment every half hour and then I was hands-free to get on with what I needed to do. It seems sensible enough but I went on increasing the intensity and duration of my routine until I was hanging literally all day, and having never jelqed I had no idea that what I was doing was many many times more than the amount of effort I would have needed to expend on just a basic newbie routine (in my defence I wasn’t capable of a newbie routine at that time). Now that I’ve been working out at the gym and have recovered and further enhanced my strength and stamina, I’m learning to jelq properly and I’m getting all of the PI’s associated with continued gains. In fact I’m measuring an eighth of an inch over my previous bp 7.5 after only the few days of intensive PE I’d resumed before I discovered both this thread and the ‘New newbie’ linear approach NEW newbie + advanced routine
I have to admit, I made some pretty good gains through hanging and traction. I’m (‘officially’) a bone-pressed 7.5 from probably bp5.5 (I don’t have an official measurement or a pic, but trust me, if there was any way in good conscience that I could have got it to look longer against my ruler than six inches, believe me, I would have been claiming ‘over six inches’. So if we consider a ‘layman’s six’ to be a bp5.5 (the actual scientifically reported average (iirc)) that means I’ve made a two inch length gain with 98%+ hanging and Penimaster (1% newbie type exercises, clamping, pumping and some power jelq)
Here’s my own contribution to the new ‘revisionist’ approach…
Hanging Guidelines / Personal & Average Maximum Gain-rate (PMGR & AMGR)
One of the reasons I left Thunders was because I began to believe that I’d maximised the possibilities for growth, both due to the plateau after what I thought was premium effort and because a survey taken here showed that the curve dropped sharply and steeply at two inches in gains, so I basically thought I’d got as much growth as I was able to get, but I’m PEing again and all the PI are pointing towards me being able to make even further gains.