Originally Posted by Kyrpa
The picture attached will explain why it is beneficial to apply from the ventral site when targeting dorsal tissue with 1 MHz.
The heat distribution does not equal the intensity distribution.
The skin below the transducer barely heats up while deeper tissue heats in a greater fashion.
These things are not up here by a chance. There is information easily available to justify our opinions.
With a 3 MHz, another strategy might suit better.
Thanks for the diagram, do you happen to know where that came from? I can’t find both diagrams together, just the one about power absorption.
Please understand, I don’t think you’re randomly saying this stuff. But to say that the information is easily available is a bit of a stretch. I spent a few hours today looking for specifically the 2 charts you linked, and could only find the power absorption, not the temperature of tissues at various depths.
Do you notice that chart shows the power 50% power deposition at 7cm, not 5cm for 1 Mhz? Why is there a difference? Are they testing fatty or non-protein tissues? Or a phantom? Because muscle absorbs alot more energy than those tissues, and collagen even more than muscle.
That’s why I’m trying to verify what exactly they were testing in the studies by which those charts were made, because the differences in material tested could significantly change the temperature profile.
I’m open to the possibility that what you’re saying is true, I just don’t have a good explanation for why, and neither do I have any empirical evidence that I can verify which would be able to contradict what seems to be the intuitive expectation regarding waves and energy.
However, as a practical matter, I have been placing the transducer dorsally for the past few days just to see, and I’m consistently showing similar strain in the immediate pre/post US sessions (I mean, referencing only the strain attributable only to the application of US). I can also feel similar amounts of heat at the target tissues. So at this point, I think practically speaking, it probably doesn’t matter that much.
I also ordered a 3 MHz transducer, as I’d like to really make sure I get good heating, and minimize the potential for reflections from the transition to the phantom, which is unavoidable to some degree.