Hi thinktank,
It seems to me that there is a problem with perspective here. If you hurt her like your honeymoon night after 35 years of marriage, then there are two possibilities. Either your wife needs to learn how to make herself more adaptable to you or, as much good sex as you’ve had, you still haven’t flipped that magic switch every woman has; the one that allows the vagina to open up perfectly.
I have always been as thick as I am long, from the first time I measured at 21 (6” BPEL x 6” EG) to now at 42 (7.125” BPEL x 7.125” EG), yet I have never been too big. This includes two virgins with narrow vaginal openings and three other women who insisted that it would be too much. Thing is, I want to reach 8.375 BPEL so you know what that means for girth; and say goodbye to oral completely.
My sweetie is average height, build and has an average vagina and a tilted uterus. According to everything I’ve read on this site so far, she should be cursing blue murder or going to the doctor on a regular, but we have the most fun — even when I jump her sleepy bones without warning or foreplay. Will she be able to handle the extra girth? I know she will because she will do whatever is necessary to guarantee our mutual satisfaction. Even now she’s taking belly dancing.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m not saying you don’t know what you’re doing, I am saying that all of us have missed the mark and that it’s possible that you have.
Clearly you care about your wife’s pleasure, but I don’t know what she is doing with her goodies to enhance your pleasure. If you’re working to be the right size for her she should be working to be the right size for you too.